Concept
Direct Versus Vicarious Liability
General rule of non-liability and the employer's own negligence
Direct Versus Vicarious Liability
The general rule of non-liability gives way in two different ways, and each exception must be sorted into one of them before it can be analyzed. A defendant is vicariously liable when the law makes the defendant pay for someone else’s tort because of a relationship between them, whether or not the defendant did anything wrong. A defendant is directly liable when it answers for its own breach of duty; the contractor’s hands may have delivered the final blow, but that is then one link in the causal chain, as it would be in any negligence case. (The sources call the person who hires the contractor the “employer” or the “owner”; this reading says “hirer.”)
The general rule exists because the usual reasons for vicarious liability are missing. As to agents who are not employees, the principal generally is not vicariously liable for their torts, even torts committed within the scope of the agency, because such agents are not part of the principal’s enterprise and the most important justifications for vicarious liability do not apply, and the hirer of an independent contractor stands in the same position.1 There are, however, exceptions, which the commentary groups into three general categories, and the category that concerns this reading is the hirer’s own fault. Apart from any rule of vicarious liability, the employer of an independent contractor is liable under ordinary negligence principles for his own negligence in dealing with the contractor, so he must exercise reasonable care to select a reasonably competent, experienced, careful, and properly equipped contractor.2
Two sections show the direct route at work. Section 410 makes the hirer liable for physical harm caused by the contractor’s act or omission when the contractor acted on orders or directions the hirer negligently gave, and it treats the harm “as though the act or omission were that of the employer himself.”3 The hirer pays because of the careless instruction, which is the hirer’s own conduct. Section 411 makes the hirer liable for physical harm to third persons caused by a failure to use reasonable care to employ a competent and careful contractor, either to do work that involves a risk of physical harm unless it is skillfully and carefully done or to perform any duty the hirer owes to third persons.4 There again the hirer pays for its own choice.
These are not the only ways a hirer can be at fault. A hirer may engage a contractor who is clearly incompetent for the work, fail to supervise, fail to require necessary precautions or specify an inappropriate manner of work, fail to inspect the work after it is done, or negligently perform work over which it retains control. The Restatement (Second) of Torts details these bases of liability in §§ 410–415, and in each the hirer is liable for its own negligence and not vicariously for the contractor’s.5 A company that selects badly, gives improper directions or equipment, or fails to stop unreasonably dangerous practices that come to its attention is liable for negligence that combines with the contractor’s to cause the harm, and this is ordinary concurrent negligence and not vicarious liability.6 Later sections take up these theories one at a time.
The label determines what the plaintiff must prove. On a direct theory the plaintiff must establish the hirer’s own duty, the hirer’s own breach, and causation, so evidence that the contractor was careless, standing alone, proves nothing against the hirer.
Plaintiffs often assert both kinds of claim in a single complaint, and the two must be kept apart. The nondelegable duty theory shows why: it will frequently allow a plaintiff injured by a contractor’s negligence to recover from the owner even though the owner exercised due care, so it belongs on the vicarious side of the line. The owner who escapes vicarious liability must still answer for its own conduct in connection with the work.7
Retained control lands on the direct side. One who entrusts work to an independent contractor but keeps control of any part of it is liable for physical harm to others, to whom the hirer owes a duty of reasonable care, that results from a failure to exercise the control with reasonable care.8 The liability attaches to how the hirer used its control and not to anything the contractor did on its own.
Hospitals show the same division in a setting where the doctrine has moved unevenly. Some older cases held that a hospital could not be vicariously liable for the negligence of physicians, even physicians it employed, because a corporation could not legally practice medicine and so could not control the physicians working in it; that holding ran contrary to the ordinary rules of agency law.9 The view has since changed radically, but not universally.10 Direct liability supplies a second route: a majority of jurisdictions let a plaintiff sue a hospital for negligent credentialing, meaning negligence in granting hospital privileges to independent physicians, although Kentucky has declined to recognize that claim on public policy grounds. The claim is not vicarious liability at all, but ordinary concurrent negligence.11
The Third Restatement keeps the same division and gives each side its own sections. Section 56 carries forward the general rule that the employer of an independent contractor has no duty with respect to the manner in which the work is performed, except as to parts of the work over which the employer retains control, and that exception is direct, not vicarious, liability. Section 55 provides for direct liability of the employer for “an activity that creates a risk of physical harm,” and also where the employer has one of the affirmative duties set out in §§ 38–44 and hires an independent contractor to perform the obligated work. Sections 57–65 provide for vicarious liability under various circumstances, similar but not identical to those in Second Restatement §§ 416–429.12 Because the literature cites both Restatements, you should be able to work in either vocabulary.13 Under either numbering, the first question is whose negligence the plaintiff relies on, the hirer’s or the contractor’s, because the answer fixes what the plaintiff must prove.