Concept
Insulation Rule and Exceptions
Nondelegable duties and inherently dangerous work exceptions
Nondelegable Duties and Dangerous Work
Insulation Rule and Exceptions
Suppose Bogart hires Bacall to resurface his driveway, and Bacall backs into the street and causes an accident. Most likely Bacall alone bears the liability.1 The example shows the rule of insulation: a person who hires an independent contractor is generally not liable for the contractor's torts, even torts that arise from the very work done for the hirer. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 409 states the rule.2 Employees are treated differently. An employer is generally liable for an employee's torts committed within the scope of employment, and that liability is called vicarious because it falls on the employer for another's wrong whether or not the employer was careful.3
The rule protects only a hirer who has a true independent contractor, and the line between contractor and employee turns on control over the details of the work. In Murrell v. Goertz, the company set policies and standards that all of its distributors and carriers had to follow. The court nevertheless affirmed, because those policies and standards did not amount to the supervision, dominion, and control over Goertz's day-to-day activities that would make him the company's servant.4 General company policies, then, do not by themselves turn a worker into a servant.5
Control also explains why the law insulates the hirer. An employee surrenders to the employer the right to direct the details of the work in exchange for a wage. An independent contractor instead commits to a specified output, and the hirer monitors that output by inspecting it against the specifications, not by supervising the contractor. A hirer who does not supervise is poorly placed to prevent negligent performance, and the law declines to charge it with the contractor's lapses.6 Pricing reinforces the allocation. The hirer knows it is avoiding a liability, the contractor knows it is assuming one, and the cost of insuring against tort liability goes into the price of the work.7
The exceptions have worn the rule down so far that it "is now primarily important as a preamble to the catalog of its exceptions."8 The Restatement mirrors that pattern: § 409 states the rule, and the twenty-four sections that follow, §§ 410–429, set out the exceptions. Those in §§ 410–415 rest on the hirer's own fault, so strictly they are not exceptions to a vicarious-liability rule. They are, however, exceptions to the rule that a hirer is not liable for harm the contractor causes, and the two sets are conveniently studied together.9 Even so, the rule still decides the ordinary case. If Bogart hires an electrical contractor to rewire his office and she negligently starts a fire during the work, most likely the contractor alone is liable.10
The exceptions fall into two groups. In the first, the hirer pays for its own negligence. A hirer must use reasonable care to select a reasonably competent, experienced, careful, and properly equipped contractor. If the work will create a foreseeable danger to third persons, ordinary care may also require the hirer to insist, in the contract or otherwise, that the contractor take the necessary safety precautions, and then to see that the contractor does so.11 A homeowner who fails to use reasonable care in choosing a plumber is negligent in her own right. If the plumber's work causes a leak that floods the neighbors' basements, the neighbors can probably recover from her.12
In the second group, the hirer is vicariously liable and may have been entirely careful. Where the safe performance of a duty matters enough to the community, the law does not let the person who owes the duty delegate it to a contractor and so escape liability for physical harm. That person answers for the contractor's negligence even though he was himself without fault.13 For work that demands special precautions, the rationale is that the hirer should know the precautions are necessary and should either make sure they are taken or bear the liability when they are not.14 Contract law supplies a parallel. A party cannot escape liability for negligent performance of its contractual obligations by delegating them to an independent contractor, because the contrary rule would give it an enormous incentive to avoid the risk of breach by handing the job to an insolvent contractor. The rule for ultrahazardous or abnormally dangerous activities answers the same incentive problem.15
This part of the chapter takes up four exceptions that apply to dangerous work and to land open to the public. Demolition work, the setting of Majestic Realty Associates v. Toti Contracting Co., is a standard illustration of work that calls for special precautions.
- Section 413 makes a hirer liable for physical harm caused by the absence of special precautions when the hirer should recognize that the work is likely to create a peculiar unreasonable risk of physical harm to others unless such precautions are taken, and the hirer fails to provide in the contract that the contractor shall take them or fails to exercise reasonable care to provide for them in some other manner.16
- Section 416 makes a hirer liable for physical harm caused by the contractor's failure to exercise reasonable care to take those precautions, even though the hirer provided for them in the contract or otherwise.17
- Section 417 makes a hirer liable to members of the public for physical harm caused by a negligent act or omission of the contractor that makes the physical condition of a public place dangerous, when the work, unless carefully done, risks that result.18
- Section 415 makes a possessor of land held open to the public liable to entrants for failing to use reasonable care to protect them against unreasonably dangerous activities or conditions created by an independent contractor or concessionaire working or operating on the land.19
Sections 413 and 415 fall within §§ 410–415 and so rest on the hirer's own fault. Sections 416 and 417 impose liability for the contractor's negligence even on a hirer who was careful, and the next section explains why the law calls duties of that kind nondelegable.