Concept
Contributory Negligence Defined
Common-law contributory negligence (complete bar)
Common-Law Contributory Negligence
Contributory Negligence Defined
Contributory negligence is conduct on the plaintiff's part that falls below the standard the plaintiff should meet for his own protection and that is a legally contributing cause, co-operating with the defendant's negligence, of the plaintiff's harm.1 Put plainly, the plaintiff failed to use reasonable care to protect himself or his property from the risk of harm, and that failure helped bring about the loss.2 The definition has two working parts: a standard of conduct the plaintiff failed to meet, and a causal link between that failure and the harm. Later sections take up each part, asking how courts measure the plaintiff's conduct, what kinds of conduct fall short, and when a shortfall counts as a legal cause.
The phrase co-operating with the defendant's negligence means that the plaintiff's carelessness need not be the only cause of the injury. In the cases where the defense applies, the defendant's negligence and the plaintiff's negligence are both causes in fact and both proximate causes of the plaintiff's harm.3 The defense therefore does not deny that the defendant's negligence caused the harm; it adds that the plaintiff's own negligence caused it too.
Because causation is part of the definition, carelessness alone does not make out the defense. Just as the plaintiff's prima facie case has the separate elements of duty, breach, causation, and damages, the defendant's affirmative defense has analogous elements: the defendant must prove not only that the plaintiff breached a duty to exercise reasonable care for his own protection, but also that the breach was both a cause in fact and a proximate cause of the harm.4 A plaintiff who was careless in some general way, but whose carelessness had nothing to do with how the injury happened, has contributed nothing to it, and the defense fails.
Three versions of one intersection collision show how the two parts work.
In the second version Mickey has a defense to plead, and at common law it does not matter that his negligence is far worse than Victoria's contributory negligence.5 The defense asks about her conduct and its causal role, not about how the two faults compare.
The defense also stands apart from the plaintiff's own case. The plaintiff's prima facie case consists of the elements sufficient to establish liability unless the defendant rebuts them.6 Those elements are duty, breach, causation, and damages.7 The defendant may prevail by showing that the plaintiff cannot prove one of them. Under the traditional common law, the defendant could also prevail by pleading and proving an affirmative defense, usually contributory negligence, assumption of risk, or an immunity.8 A defendant who says he drove with due care attacks the plaintiff's case; a defendant who says that, even if he was negligent, the plaintiff's inattention helped cause the crash raises the defense.
The Restatement writes the plaintiff's own conduct into its statement of a negligence action, which it frames in four conditions:
- The interest invaded is protected against unintentional invasion.9
- The actor's conduct is negligent with respect to the other, or to a class of persons within which he is included.10
- The actor's conduct is a legal cause of the invasion.11
- The other has not so conducted himself as to disable himself from bringing an action for such invasion.12
The first three conditions concern the invaded interest and the defendant's conduct. The fourth looks at the plaintiff, and contributory negligence is the leading example of conduct that can disable a plaintiff in this way. A plaintiff who satisfies the first three conditions can therefore still lose at the fourth.
A second Restatement formulation reaches the same place from the other direction. One requirement for liability is that the actor's conduct be a legal cause of the harm; another is that the actor have no defense applicable to the particular claim.13 Contributory negligence is such a defense, so a defendant whose conduct was a legal cause of the harm may still escape liability because the plaintiff's own lapse supplies the defense.
At common law, established contributory negligence completely barred recovery when the harm was partly the plaintiff's own fault.14 The next section takes up that complete bar. Most states have since abolished the doctrine and adopted a comparative-negligence scheme in its place.15 The vocabulary survives in other fields: product-liability treatments list contributory negligence and comparative fault as separate defenses, beside assumption of risk and misuse, among the defenses based on user conduct.16 Because comparative negligence now applies in at least some negligence cases in all but a few states, the full defense is largely a thing of the past; yet contributory negligence remains the reference point for the modern reforms.17