Concept
Comparing the Forms
Comparative negligence (modern apportionment)
Comparing the Forms
Every comparative negligence statute does the same subtraction, reducing the plaintiff's damages by her percentage of fault, and the statutes differ only in whether they ask a question first. Washington's pure statute asks none: the claimant's contributory fault reduces the award proportionately but “does not bar recovery.”1 The modified statutes add a gate. One typical text lets the plaintiff recover only if her negligence “was less than the causal negligence of the party or parties against whom a claim is made,” so a plaintiff at 45 percent fault recovers 55 percent of her damages and a plaintiff at 70 percent recovers nothing.2 Another, §895.045, lets her recover if her negligence “was not greater than the negligence of the person against whom recovery is sought.”3 A plaintiff who clears either gate recovers exactly what the pure form would have paid, so the forms part company only where a gate closes.4
That shared structure dictates one method for every regime, and the method starts with the rule, because the jury's percentage is a finding of fact whose legal effect depends on the jurisdiction. On identical findings, a plaintiff found 60 percent at fault recovers 40 percent of the damages in one state and nothing in another.
Steps 2 and 4 are identical everywhere, and step 3 is where the regimes part. The most common slip is to run step 4 before step 3, subtracting the plaintiff's percentage from the damages and announcing the remainder as a recovery. That is correct only for a plaintiff who has already cleared the threshold. Under the pure form a plaintiff at 100 percent has nothing to recover, because that finding amounts to saying the defendant was not negligent at all,5 and in a modified jurisdiction a plaintiff at 60 percent has no remainder to compute. One variation survives outside these four regimes: South Dakota alone apportions damages only when the plaintiff's negligence “was slight in comparison with the negligence of the defendant.”6
Two findings from the printing-press problem put numbers on the differences. In the first, Paine's hand is caught in a press operated by Burke. The jury fixes his damages at $60,000 and finds each of them 50 percent at fault.7 A pure jurisdiction reduces the award by Paine's 50 percent, and he recovers $30,000.8 A 51 percent bar (“not greater than”) gives the same $30,000, because Paine's fault does not exceed Burke's and the usual reduction follows.9 A 50 percent bar (“not as great as”) gives him nothing, because his negligence is as great as Burke's.10 Contributory negligence bars him too. The first two outcomes match for the reason already given: a modified plaintiff who clears the gate receives the pure result. The tie is the one finding on which the two modified forms part, and it matters in practice because a 50/50 apportionment appeals to juries and is therefore common.11
In the second finding, Paine sues both Burke and Calkins, who had recently repaired the press. Damages are again $60,000, and the jury finds Paine 65 percent at fault, Burke 15 percent, and Calkins 20 percent.12 Under the pure form Paine recovers $21,000, the $60,000 less 65 percent of it, though he was far more negligent than either defendant. Both modified forms bar him entirely, because his 65 percent exceeds each defendant's share and also their combined 35 percent, so the way a statute measures the comparison makes no difference here. Contributory negligence bars him as well. This case shows the sharpest contrast between the systems: only the pure form pays a plaintiff who is primarily at fault.13 How the $21,000 is collected from two liable defendants turns on joint and several liability, which this chapter reaches later.
Side by side, the two findings produce these results:
| Jury finding ($60,000 damages) | Contributory negligence | Pure | 50 percent bar | 51 percent bar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paine 50%, Burke 50% | $0 | $30,000 | $0 | $30,000 |
| Paine 65%, Burke 15%, Calkins 20% | $0 | $21,000 | $0 | $0 |
Suppose instead that Paine and two defendants are each 33⅓ percent at fault, again on $60,000. The result then depends on a question the forms do not answer by themselves: whose fault is Paine's measured against? In a pure jurisdiction the question never arises, and Paine recovers $60,000 less one-third, or $40,000. Some modified statutes compare the plaintiff with the defendants' combined fault. Paine's 33⅓ percent is then well below their 66⅔ percent, and he recovers the same $40,000 under either modified form.14 Other statutes measure the plaintiff against each defendant separately; §895.045 provides that the plaintiff's negligence “shall be measured separately against the negligence of each person found to be causally negligent.”15 On that comparison Paine's fault equals each defendant's. The 50 percent bar would bar him, while the 51 percent bar lets him recover, with a $40,000 judgment against each defendant if joint and several liability applies.16 Step 3 therefore cannot be run until the comparison is known, a point developed under Multiple Defendants below.
Three patterns survive any change of numbers:
- Below half, every comparative form gives the same answer: the damages reduced by the plaintiff's percentage.17
- At exactly half, the 50 percent bar parts from the pure form and the 51 percent bar, and the plaintiff recovers nothing under the first and half the damages under the others.18
- Above half, only the pure form pays.
Contributory negligence yields zero in all of these, because each involves a plaintiff whose own negligence contributed, and under that rule any contributing fault bars recovery.
When a problem does not say which rule governs, the answer should state the result under each rule that might. Thirty-three states use a modified form, thirteen use the pure form, and contributory negligence survives in some jurisdictions, so no single rule can be assumed.19 The efficient order is contributory negligence first, then comparative negligence, then the pure and modified forms within it. Because those forms differ only where the plaintiff's fault reaches half, a plaintiff well below half needs only one comparative answer.
When a problem quotes the statute, its wording sorts the regime without further information:
- A statute under which contributory fault reduces the award and says nothing about a threshold is a pure statute, as Washington's is.20
- A statute that allows recovery only if the plaintiff's negligence was less than the defendant's is a 50 percent bar, and a plaintiff found equally at fault loses.21
- A statute that allows recovery if the plaintiff's negligence was not greater than the defendant's is a 51 percent bar, as New Jersey's and §895.045 are, and a plaintiff found equally at fault recovers half.22
A pure statute is recognized by what it leaves out, since a modified statute has to address the plaintiff whose fault is as great as, or greater than, the defendant's. Two questions remain open here: whose fault counts in the comparison when several actors contributed, and how the reduction works when both parties are injured and each sues the other. Later sections take up each.