Concept
The Voluntariness Requirement
Voluntariness of the plaintiff's choice
Voluntariness in Assumption of Risk
The Voluntariness Requirement
A plaintiff can understand a danger perfectly and still not have assumed it. Restatement (Second) of Torts § 496E(1) states the rule: “A plaintiff does not assume a risk of harm unless he voluntarily accepts the risk.”1 The defense rests on consent, and a person cannot consent to a danger she does not know about or to one that is forced upon her.2 Those two limits become two elements: the plaintiff’s encounter with the risk must be informed, and it must be voluntary.3 This unit concerns the second.
The requirement matters because of what the defense does when it succeeds. Assumption of risk defeats or reduces the defendant’s liability even though the defendant owed a duty and was negligent.4 Courts in comparative negligence states found it logically or morally difficult to defend a system in which the plaintiff’s fault merely reduced damages when it was called contributory negligence but barred recovery entirely when it was called assumption of risk.5 Most of those states responded by statute or judicial decision.6 A defense with consequences this heavy should rest on a real choice, and voluntariness is the element that tests for one.
The Maryland court in ADM P'ship v. Martin stated the limit in plain terms: “[e]ven where the plaintiff does not protest, the risk is not assumed where the conduct of the defendant has left him no reasonable alternative. Where the defendant puts him to a choice of evils, there is a species of duress, which destroys the idea of freedom of election.”7 Section 496E(2) turns that idea into a rule. A plaintiff’s acceptance of a risk is not voluntary if the defendant’s tortious conduct has left him no reasonable alternative course of conduct8 in order to avert harm to himself or another,9 or to exercise or protect a right or privilege of which the defendant has no right to deprive him.10 The sections that follow take up each form of forced choice in turn.
In practice, the inquiry reduces to a short sequence of questions about the plaintiff’s situation at the moment of the encounter.
Rides with an impaired driver show the questions at work. A passenger who consents to ride with an intoxicated driver is the typical assumption-of-risk plaintiff, and some courts permit the defense in that situation even though one ordinarily does not assume the risk of another’s future negligence.11 In Young v. Wheby, the passenger accepted such a ride and was held to have chosen the danger voluntarily. Ridgway v. Yenny supplies the contrast: there the passengers’ continued exposure was not truly voluntary, because no other way out was open to them. How well the passengers understood the danger does not separate the cases. What separates them is whether a reasonable alternative was open. Commentators add that the real basis of the defense in the intoxicated-driver cases is the passenger’s unreasonable decision to get into the car, and they would treat those cases as contributory negligence rather than assumption of risk.12
Silence does not make a choice voluntary. The Maryland court’s formulation makes the test the plaintiff’s real options, not her visible reluctance, so a plaintiff who never objects may still have lacked any reasonable alternative.13 A later section returns to protests and promises to repair.
The defendant carries the burden on all of this. Assumption of risk is an affirmative defense that the defendant must plead and prove. Duty is a question of law for the court, but the defense is a question of fact for the jury.14 It requires actual knowledge of the particular risk, appreciation of its magnitude, and voluntary encountering of the risk, and the defendant bears the burdens of pleading, production, and proof.15 Each element probes one person’s state of mind, including the extent to which her choice was free and voluntary. The determination is therefore peculiarly one of fact for the jury, except in “plain, palpable, and indisputable cases” where the facts show a risk the plaintiff fully comprehended and freely accepted as a matter of law.16 A defendant who offers proof of knowledge alone, with no evidence about the plaintiff’s alternatives, will usually face a jury rather than win on motion.