Concept
Counting Publications
Publication, republication, and the single publication rule
Counting Publications
Section 577A of the Restatement (Second) of Torts supplies the count when a defendant communicates defamatory matter more than once, or to more than one person.1 The default is that each of several communications to a third person by the same defamer is a separate publication.2 Two exceptions follow. A single communication heard at the same time by two or more third persons is one publication.3 So is any one edition of a book or newspaper, any one radio or television broadcast, one exhibition of a motion picture, or a similar aggregate communication.4
Publication is a communication to someone other than the plaintiff, so a communication to a new listener or reader on a new occasion is a new act that can lower the plaintiff's standing with a new audience. The default counts it as a new publication. A defamer who tells one person on Monday and another on Friday has made two, and each supports its own claim. Left unchecked, the same default would give a plaintiff a separate claim for every copy of a mass-circulated book or issue. The single publication rule prevents that result: it gives the plaintiff one claim for each mass publication and no claim for every book or issue in the run.5
The unit being counted therefore decides how many causes of action one defamatory statement can generate, and with them how many limitation periods. The default ties each claim to a distinct occasion. The two groupings keep one act of wide dissemination from becoming thousands of lawsuits over the same words. What a single-publication classification does to the plaintiff's remedies is taken up in the section after this one.
Each Communication Is Separate
Section 577A(1) sets the starting point: except as subsections (2) and (3) provide, each of several communications to a third person by the same defamer is a separate publication.6 A separate publication is its own tort, with its own recipient and its own cause of action. The comment extends the rule to a retelling heard by someone who already knows the charge: “each communication of the same defamatory matter by the same defamer, whether to a new person or to the same person, is a separate and distinct publication, for which a separate cause of action arises.” An opinion quoting that comment adds the point that organizes the rest of this unit. The “single publication rule” is an exception to this general rule.7
Defamation is a communication whose meaning harms reputation, either by lowering the plaintiff in the estimation of the community or by deterring others from associating or dealing with the plaintiff.8 Each communication is a separate act with its own audience and its own chance to cause that harm, and the default counts the acts one by one.
A leading English case, Duke of Brunswick v. Harmer, decided in 1849, shows how far the common law carried the default. An issue of a newspaper had been published in 1830. Seventeen years later the defendant sold a single copy of it, and the plaintiff sued for libel on that sale. The statute-of-limitations plea was overruled because each sale or delivery of a copy of the offending material gave rise to a new and separate cause of action.9
The court treated the sale as the publication. A limitation period runs from the publication sued on, and the publication sued on was the sale, not the printing in 1830. The age of the original printing therefore said nothing about when the defendant's exposure would end. Under the default no point exists at which an old accusation goes stale, because exposure lasts as long as the defendant keeps communicating the matter.
The count follows the defamer's communications and not the size of the audience. The treasurer reached two people and made three publications. A speaker who makes one statement to a hall of listeners who hear it at the same time makes one publication under § 577A(2), however many people were present.10 The next subsection develops that exception.
Two limits keep the default from being misapplied. First, the rule counts communications by the same defamer, so a third person's retelling is not one of the original defamer's publications. The original defamer answers for special harm from that retelling only if the repeater was privileged to repeat it, the original defamer authorized or intended it, or it was reasonably to be expected.11 The repeater is subject to liability as if he had originally published the matter, unless he only delivered or transmitted another's defamation.12 Those rules are covered in the earlier sections on repetition (§ 576) and republication (§ 578). Second, each counted communication must go to a third person, so a retelling that only the plaintiff heard adds nothing to the count.
One Utterance, Many Listeners
Section 577A(2) is the first limit on the default: a single communication heard at the same time by two or more third persons is a single publication.14 The subsection counts what the defamer did, and the number of people present when the defamer did it does not matter. A speaker who makes one statement on one occasion to listeners gathered at that moment has performed one act of communication. That act supports one cause of action whether two people heard it or two hundred. The words that carry the rule are at the same time.
The grouping follows from what the default counts. Under § 577A(1), separate communications are separate publications because each new occasion is a new act by the defamer that reaches a mind that had not heard the charge.15 Listeners who hear one utterance together received it from a single act, and once the speaker begins, the size of the room is outside the speaker's control. If every listener counted, the number of claims would rise with attendance although the defendant did nothing more, and identical words spoken once could produce two lawsuits or two hundred. Counting the act ties the number of claims to the defendant's own choices about when to speak. The harm in each listener's mind does not disappear, and it belongs to the one claim.
Occasion and timing move the count. Listeners who receive the words together make one publication, and listeners who receive them one after another, or on different days, make several, even when the speaker and the words are identical.16 A resident who sat in the hall and hears the accusation again at lunch has received a new communication, and the earlier exposure does not absorb it.
On an exam, a fact pattern will usually say how many people heard a statement and invite a count of publications. Start by finding the occasions on which the defendant actually spoke or wrote, then ask whether the listeners on each occasion heard the communication together. If the facts describe a printed edition, a broadcast, or a film exhibition instead of a spoken statement, § 577A(3) governs, and the next subsection takes it up.17
Editions, Broadcasts, and Exhibitions
Section 577A(3) is the second grouping: any one edition of a book or newspaper, any one radio or television broadcast, any one exhibition of a motion picture, or any similar aggregate communication is a single publication.19 Subsection (2) groups people who hear one utterance together. Subsection (3) reaches mass dissemination, where recipients rarely receive the matter at the same instant but all receive it from one release. The unit counted is the edition, the broadcast, or the exhibition, so the number of copies printed, sets tuned in, or seats filled does not change the count. A newspaper that prints one edition and sells it in many cities over several weeks has made one publication, and the plaintiff has one claim for it.
The reason follows from what § 577A(1) counts. Separate communications are separate publications because each new act can reach a mind that had not heard the charge.20 A print run or a broadcast is one act of mass dissemination. The publisher decides once to release the edition, and the printing, shipping, and selling carry out that decision. If every copy or viewer counted, one issue read by a hundred thousand people would give the plaintiff a hundred thousand claims against a defendant who made one choice. The size of the run changes the audience and leaves the number of claims where it was.
Copies that circulate after the first release stay part of that release. For purposes of the statute of limitations, a book, magazine, or newspaper has a single publication date, defined as when it was first posted or made generally available to the public, and copies of the original are still part of the single publication.21 A book whose copies keep selling for years has therefore not produced a stream of new claims. Under the older common-law rule, by contrast, the sale of one copy of a seventeen-year-old newspaper began a new action.22 The single publication rule displaces that result, and the next section develops what follows for limitations.
The grouping stops at the edge of each release. A new edition of a book is a new publication and supports a new cause of action.23 The rule counts “any one” broadcast, so a second airing is a second broadcast and a separate publication, and the same holds for each separate exhibition of a motion picture.24 The wire-story rule rests on the same reasoning. When a hundred newspapers each publish in their own editions a news report supplied by the Associated Press, a hundred publications result, and each is separately actionable.25 Each paper chose to run the report in its own edition for its own readers, so the hundred decisions are separate acts by separate publishers, and a common source does not group them.
The sources fix the principle that a new edition is a new publication, but they do not say what makes one edition different from another. When a work reappears in revised or different form, an answer should argue both sides. The plaintiff will say the reappearance is a fresh release that the defendant decided on and carried out anew. The defendant will say the work and its content are unchanged, so treating the new form as a new publication would revive the multiplicity of claims the rule exists to prevent. Flag the facts that favor each side, such as changed content or a separate decision to release, and treat the question as open.