Also known as:derivative instruments · derivatives instrument · derivatives instruments · derivative · financial derivative
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A civil suit brought in the right of a corporation, LLC, or limited partnership to recover for injury to the entity.
Sources & Authorities
How it applies
Common Examples
6
Shareholder Challenges Swap Trade
Delta Dynamics entered into an interest-rate swap whose value moved with Treasury yields. A shareholder brought suit alleging the trade harmed the corporation. Because the shareholder was not a record owner at the time of the trade, the court dismissed the action under the contemporaneous-ownership requirement.
Member Sues Over Futures Loss
Dustin Donovan held a membership interest in an LLC that traded commodity futures. After large losses, he filed a derivative action without first demanding that the managers investigate. The court dismissed the suit because demand was not shown to be futile.
Limited Partner Attacks Option Deal
Put it into practice
Test Yourself
10
Practice Questions5
· 18 primary sources
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Cases
Federal Rules
Uniform Acts
Model Codes
Restatements
Hornbooks
Study Supplements
Dictionaries
Derek Douglas became a limited partner after the partnership had already written uncovered call options. He later sued to recover losses from those options. The court held he lacked standing because his partnership interest did not devolve from a partner who held status when the options were written.
Court Stays Inquiry Into Swaps
Duarte Shipping's board began an internal review of allegedly unauthorized currency swaps. A shareholder who had filed a derivative complaint moved to proceed immediately. The court stayed the action to allow the inquiry to finish.
Recovery Flows to Company
Decker Electronics prevailed in a derivative suit over mismanaged equity derivatives. The judgment proceeds were paid directly to the LLC rather than to the plaintiff member who brought the action.
Partnership Forms Review Committee
Duffy Construction's limited partnership was named in a derivative suit concerning interest-rate derivatives. The partnership appointed a special litigation committee that moved to stay discovery while it investigated whether continuing the action served the partnership's interests.
Common questions
Frequently Asked
4
What must a plaintiff show to maintain a derivative action involving corporate use of derivative instruments?+
The plaintiff must have been a shareholder or member at the time the challenged conduct occurred and must remain one when the action is commenced. In addition, the plaintiff ordinarily must make a demand on the board or managers unless demand would be futile.
Who receives the proceeds when a derivative action over financial instruments succeeds?+
Any recovery belongs to the corporation, LLC, or partnership, not to the individual plaintiff. The plaintiff may receive reasonable expenses and attorneys' fees from the recovery if the action succeeds in whole or in part.
When may a court stay a derivative proceeding concerning derivative instruments?+
If the entity begins an inquiry into the allegations, the court may stay the action for the period it deems appropriate to allow the inquiry to conclude.
Can a person who acquires an interest after the challenged transaction bring a derivative suit?+
Generally no. Standing requires ownership at the time the conduct occurred, unless the interest devolved by operation of law or under the governing agreement from someone who held the interest at that time.
Trusts and Estates Trusts and Future InterestsFuture interests · Powers of appointmentUBEIntermediate