Also known as:divisions in kind · partition in kind
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A method of partition by which a court divides commonly owned real property into physically distinct and separately titled parcels allocated to each co-tenant according to their fractional interests. The method is generally preferred because it allows each owner to retain an actual portion of the land rather than receiving only monetary proceeds. A court may decline to order division in kind when physical characteristics of the land or external legal constraints such as zoning or conservation easements render a fair and equitable physical division impossible.
Sources & Authorities
How it applies
Common Examples
2
Wetland Conservation Easement Division
Marcel and Lillian hold a 50-acre reclaimed wetland as tenants in common subject to a recorded conservation easement requiring the land to function as one contiguous ecological unit. Marcel proposes splitting the parcel along an access road into two 25-acre segments. The uniform wetland features and easement restrictions prevent any physical division from preserving the required hydrology and habitat connectivity, so the court orders a sale of the entire parcel with division of proceeds.
Farm Irrigation Well Partition
Scott and Elena hold a 400-acre farm as joint tenants. The farm's sole authorized irrigation well cannot be duplicated or separated under state water regulations. Scott seeks division into two 200-acre parcels with an access easement over the well. Because the regulations bar any effective separation of water rights, the court determines that physical division would leave one parcel unusable for agriculture and orders a sale instead.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Cases
Uniform Acts
Casebooks
Schnell v. Schnell346 N.W.2d 713, 716 (N.D. 1984)
Common questions
Frequently Asked
4
When will a court order partition by sale instead of division in kind?+
A court orders partition by sale when physical characteristics of the land or external legal constraints such as zoning rules or conservation easements make a fair and equitable physical division impossible. The preference for division in kind yields when any resulting parcels would be unusable or unbuildable.
Supporting sources
Does the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act change the preference for division in kind?+
The Act preserves the preference for partition in kind but requires the court to consider specific factors including whether division would materially reduce aggregate fair market value. If great prejudice to the cotenants as a group would result, the court must order a sale instead.
Supporting sources
Can co-tenants aggregate their interests when requesting division in kind?+
Yes. The court must approve a request by two or more cotenants to have their individual interests aggregated when considering whether to order partition in kind.
Supporting sources
What happens if the court orders division in kind but the parcels have unequal value?+
The court may require one or more cotenants to pay others amounts that, together with the value of the in-kind distributions, make the partition just and proportionate to the fractional interests held.
Supporting sources
436 A.2d 27Property
…and the appointment of a committee to conduct said partition. The trial court, after a hearing, concluded that a partition in kind could not be had without “material injury” to the respective rights of the parties, and therefore ordered that the property be sold at auction by a committee and that the proceeds be paid…