Johnson entered into an agreement to purchase land and paid a deposit toward the purchase price. The land had been devised under the will of Royal Whiton, specifically passing to his five grandchildren pursuant to the seventh clause of that will. Subsequently, the five grandchildren executed a deed conveying the property and tendered it to Johnson as the buyer.
Johnson refused to accept the deed, asserting that Sarah A. Whiton, one of the grandchildren, lacked the ability to convey a fee simple absolute in the land due to the terms of the will. As a result, Johnson commenced this action to recover the deposit paid under the purchase agreement.
The seventh clause of Royal Whiton's will contained the following language regarding the disposition to his granddaughter: “After the decease of all my children, I give, devise, and bequeath to my granddaughter, Sarah A. Whiton, and her heirs on her father’s side, one third part of all my estate, both real and personal, and to my other grandchildren and their heirs respectively the remainder, to be divided in equal parts between them.” This dispute over the quality of title offered by the tendered deed was presented to the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, where Holmes, J., considered the matter and issued the court's opinion.
View case