Also known as: false statements of material fact · material misrepresentation
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A representation of an existing fact that is untrue and would reasonably affect a decision in a legal proceeding or transaction.
Frederick Ferguson represents a client in a contract dispute before Judge Harlan. During a hearing Ferguson tells the court that his client delivered all required documents on the agreed date, even though Ferguson knows the delivery occurred two weeks late. The tribunal relies on the statement to deny the opposing party's motion for sanctions.
Fabian Flynn agrees to buy a commercial building from Frontier Capital after the seller states that the roof was replaced the previous year. The statement is false. Flynn discovers the roof is original and twenty years old. Because the misrepresentation induced his assent, Flynn may avoid the contract.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Fumiko Fujimoto's law firm website states that she has never lost a jury trial. In reality she has lost three. A prospective client sees the claim, retains her, and later learns the truth. The false statement about her services violates the prohibition on misleading communications.
Frank Fisher tells opposing counsel that his client has no insurance coverage for the claim. Fisher knows the client carries a one-million-dollar policy. The false statement leads opposing counsel to recommend a low settlement offer. The misrepresentation concerns a material fact in the negotiation.
Forrest Falconer applies for bar admission and answers no to a question asking whether any employer has ever found him dishonest. He had received a formal reprimand for falsifying expense reports. The bar later learns of the reprimand. The answer constitutes a knowing false statement of material fact in the admissions process.
A fact is material when it would reasonably influence the tribunal, admissions authority, or third party in reaching a decision. The bar application questions in the MC problems treated prior findings of dishonesty as material because they directly bear on honesty and fitness.
Yes. The rules prohibit knowingly making a false statement. The essay answers emphasize that the lawyer or applicant must possess actual awareness of the falsity at the time the statement is made.
Yes. The MC explanations state that a knowing false statement of material fact during the admissions process remains sanctionable after admission because the integrity of the process depends on truthful disclosure.
In contracts a material misrepresentation that induces justified reliance makes the contract voidable. In professional responsibility the same type of statement triggers discipline when made to a tribunal, third person, or admissions authority.