Also known as:good faith duty · duty of good faith · duties of good faith · good faith · implied covenant of good faith · duty of good faith and fair dealing
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
An obligation requiring parties in legal relationships to act honestly and fairly without intent to defraud or take unconscionable advantage. The duty is measured by whether the actor had a legitimate basis for the conduct and avoided bad-faith manipulation of rules or rights.
Sources & Authorities· 37 primary sources
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Cases
Statutes
Federal Rules
Uniform Acts
Model Codes
Common Law
Restatements
How it applies
Common Examples
6
Mortgage Acceleration Dispute
Gulfstream Aviation missed two mortgage installments on its hangar property. Guardian Insurance, the mortgagee, declared the full balance due and scheduled foreclosure without first providing notice or an opportunity to cure. A court later found the acceleration invalid because Guardian failed to exercise the right in good faith.
Corporate Deposition Notice
Gable Construction received a Rule 30(b)(6) notice listing eight broad topics for examination. Its counsel conferred with opposing counsel about narrowing the topics and designating appropriate officers. The parties reached an agreement on the scope before the deposition date, satisfying the good-faith conferral requirement.
Derivative Suit Dismissal Motion
Shareholders of Great Lakes Steel filed a derivative suit alleging self-dealing by two directors. The board appointed a committee of qualified directors that conducted interviews and reviewed documents before concluding that continued litigation was not in the corporation's best interests. The court dismissed the suit because the committee acted in good faith after a reasonable inquiry.
Client Advice on Tax Strategy
Attorney Gina Griffin advised client Glenn Gross on a proposed transaction that carried potential fraud exposure. She explained the legal risks, possible penalties, and alternative structures that would achieve the same economic result without violating the law. The advice constituted a good-faith effort to determine the validity and scope of the governing rules.
Reporter Grand Jury Subpoena
A newspaper reporter received a grand jury subpoena seeking the identity of a confidential source. The prosecutor issued the subpoena as part of a good-faith investigation into public corruption rather than to harass the press. The reporter was required to appear and testify because no constitutional privilege protected the source under these circumstances.
Foreclosure Process Compliance
Guardian Insurance began nonjudicial foreclosure against homeowner Gregory Gates after he defaulted on payments. The servicer sent all required notices, offered a loss-mitigation review, and maintained accurate records throughout the process. Because the creditor acted in good faith at every stage, the foreclosure sale was upheld against later challenge.
Common questions
Frequently Asked
6
What conduct satisfies the good-faith requirement in mortgage acceleration?+
The mortgagee must have a legitimate commercial reason for accelerating and must not accelerate solely to obtain an unfair advantage or to pressure the mortgagor into an unfavorable modification. Some jurisdictions also require prior notice and a cure period before acceleration is effective.
Does good faith in a Rule 30(b)(6) conference require the parties to reach agreement?+
No. The rule requires only a good-faith effort to confer about the matters for examination. The parties need not reach agreement, but they must attempt to narrow issues and identify appropriate designees before the deposition proceeds.
When may a court dismiss a derivative suit based on a good-faith determination?
+
A court may dismiss if a majority of qualified directors, after conducting a reasonable inquiry, conclude in good faith that continued litigation is not in the corporation's best interests. The plaintiff must allege particularized facts showing the determination was not made in good faith or after reasonable inquiry.
How does the good-faith duty limit a lawyer's assistance to a client?+
A lawyer may not assist conduct the lawyer knows is criminal or fraudulent. The lawyer may, however, discuss legal consequences and help the client make a good-faith effort to determine the validity, scope, or application of the law.
Does the First Amendment protect a reporter who refuses to testify before a grand jury?+
No. Requiring a reporter to appear and testify in a good-faith grand-jury investigation does not violate the First Amendment, and no constitutional reporter's privilege exists to withhold confidential sources.
What does the good-faith requirement add to foreclosure procedures?+
Every person governed by the act must comply with its requirements and act in good faith throughout the foreclosure process. This duty supplements the separate obligation to proceed in a commercially reasonable manner.
Business Associations Agency and PartnershipSpecial rules concerning limited partnerships · Economic rights of limited partnersUBEIntermediate