Also known as: managerial lawyer · supervisory lawyer · managerial lawyers · supervisory lawyers · managing lawyers · supervising attorneys
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
Lawyers who possess managerial authority in a law firm or direct supervisory authority over other lawyers. Partners and supervising attorneys have an obligation to provide reasonable training and oversight to other lawyers. Failure to supervise can itself be a basis for discipline when it contributes to ethical violations.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Dana chairs the environmental practice group and directs associate Miguel to certify that all soil test reports have been produced while knowingly omitting an older batch showing higher contamination. Miguel follows the instruction and signs the certification. Because Dana ordered the specific conduct, she bears responsibility for the resulting violation even though she did not sign the document herself.
Senior partner William reviews corporate documents showing a client's principal place of business is in State C yet signs a verified complaint drafted by associate Tara alleging it is in State B to secure venue. William takes no steps to correct the allegation. His ratification of the inaccurate filing while possessing direct supervisory authority subjects him to discipline for the misstatement.
A supervisory lawyer is responsible when the lawyer orders the conduct, knowingly ratifies it, or knows of the conduct at a time when its consequences can still be avoided or mitigated yet fails to take reasonable remedial action. Responsibility also arises when a lawyer with managerial authority fails to implement reasonable measures ensuring that the firm promotes compliance by all lawyers.
Supporting sources
No. A supervisory lawyer cannot avoid responsibility by delegating execution of an unethical instruction to a subordinate. Responsibility attaches when the supervisor orders the conduct or, with knowledge of the specific conduct, ratifies it regardless of whose name appears on the document.
Supporting sources
A lawyer with firm-wide managerial authority must make reasonable efforts to ensure the organization has measures in place that give reasonable assurance all lawyers conform to the rules. In a large department this typically requires system-wide training, written protocols, and reporting mechanisms rather than bare delegation or informal reminders.
Supporting sources
Yes. Once a supervisor acquires knowledge of conduct whose consequences can be avoided or mitigated, the supervisor must take reasonable remedial action. Limiting review to signature checks or directing only future caution without addressing the known issue constitutes a failure to act.
Supporting sources