In his will, Jacob Heller created a trust to benefit his wife Bertha Heller during her life, with the residuary estate held in trust. He appointed his brother Frank Heller as initial trustee, to be succeeded by his sons Herbert and Alan Heller. The remainder beneficiaries were his daughters Suzanne Heller and Faith Willinger, each with a 30% share, and his sons Herbert and Alan Heller, each with a 20% share. Bertha was to receive the greater of $40,000 or the total income of the trust annually.
Jacob Heller died in 1986, survived by his wife Bertha. When Frank Heller died in 1997, Herbert and Alan became trustees. From 1997 until 2001, Bertha received an average annual income of approximately $190,000 from the trust.
In September 2001, New York enacted legislation including the optional unitrust provision under EPTL 11-2.4, effective January 1, 2002. In March 2003, trustees Herbert and Alan elected to apply the unitrust provision, notifying beneficiaries Bertha, Suzanne, and Faith. They sought retroactive application to January 1, 2002, which reduced Bertha's annual income to approximately $70,000.
Sandra Davis, as attorney-in-fact for Bertha Heller, commenced a proceeding in Surrogate’s Court on August 1, 2003, moving for summary judgment to annul the unitrust election, revoke the trustees' letters, and determine that the election could not be retroactive. Surrogate’s Court granted the motion regarding retroactivity but denied annulment of the election. Davis appealed, and the trustees cross-appealed. The Appellate Division affirmed the denial of annulment and reversed on retroactivity, granting leave and certifying a question to the Court of Appeals.
View case