Also known as: renounce · renounces · renounced · renouncing · renunciations
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
2 senses
An affirmative defense available when a person who has taken substantial steps toward a crime abandons the effort or prevents its commission under circumstances showing a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal purpose. The defense requires that the decision to desist not be prompted by increased risk of detection or a mere postponement of the crime. It applies to attempt, conspiracy, and solicitation under the Model Penal Code framework.
The express or tacit abandonment of a right or claim without transferring it to another party. In probate administration a personal representative may renounce a will's compensation provision before qualifying and claim reasonable compensation instead. In commercial paper a holder may discharge a party's obligation by a signed record renouncing rights against that party.
Each sense below has its own examples, sources, and questions.
An affirmative defense available when a person who has taken substantial steps toward a crime abandons the effort or prevents its commission under circumstances showing a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal purpose. The defense requires that the decision to desist not be prompted by increased risk of detection or a mere postponement of the crime. It applies to attempt, conspiracy, and solicitation under the Model Penal Code framework.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Ruby Rivera loaded a gun and drove to the victim's house intending to commit murder. Halfway there she stopped, deleted the victim's address from her phone, and drove home without approaching the house. Because her decision reflected a complete and voluntary change of mind rather than fear of detection, the renunciation prevents liability for attempted murder.
Ricardo Rojas approached a friend and offered money to assault a rival. The next day Rojas told the friend to ignore the request. Under common law the completed solicitation cannot be undone by later withdrawal, so the renunciation does not shield Rojas from the solicitation charge.
Rina Rahman and a colleague agreed to falsify safety reports for a construction project. Rahman later deleted the false data from the shared server, notified the client of the accurate results, and halted the shipment. Because she thwarted the conspiracy through a complete and voluntary renunciation, the defense shields her from conspiracy liability.
The defendant must prove that he abandoned the criminal effort or prevented its commission under circumstances manifesting a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal purpose. The decision must not be motivated by increased risk of detection or by a plan to resume the crime later or against a different victim.
Supporting sources
No. Once the solicitation is made, subsequent withdrawal or renunciation ordinarily does not constitute a defense. The offense is complete at the moment the solicitation occurs.
Supporting sources
The express or tacit abandonment of a right or claim without transferring it to another party. In probate administration a personal representative may renounce a will's compensation provision before qualifying and claim reasonable compensation instead. In commercial paper a holder may discharge a party's obligation by a signed record renouncing rights against that party.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Ronald Reed was named executor in his aunt's will, which set his fee at a flat $2,000. Before filing the petition to qualify, Reed submitted a written renunciation of that fee provision to the probate court and requested reasonable compensation instead. The court may award him reasonable compensation because the renunciation occurred before qualification.
Rebecca Ross held a promissory note signed by her former business partner. She signed a record stating she renounced all rights to collect on the note and delivered it to the partner. The renunciation discharges the partner's obligation to pay the instrument.
A personal representative may renounce the will's compensation provision before qualifying and then claim reasonable compensation, provided there is no separate contract with the decedent fixing compensation. The renunciation must be in writing and filed with the court.
Supporting sources
The holder may discharge the obligation by an intentional voluntary act such as surrender or cancellation of the instrument or by agreeing not to sue or otherwise renouncing rights against the party in a signed record.
Supporting sources
…before viability is the most central principle of Roe v. Wade . It is a rule of law and a component of liberty we cannot renounce. On the other side of the equation is the interest of the State in the protection of potential life. The Roe Court recognized the State's "important and legitimate interest in protecting…
…if the object of that legislation could be accomplished by banning a wider category of speech. This appears to be a general renunciation
…aliens unlawfully present in the United States, persons dishonorably discharged from the Armed Forces, persons who have renounced their citizenship, and persons who have been subjected to certain restraining orders or been convicted of a misdemeanor offense involving domestic violence. §§ 922(d) and (g). In 1993,…
…rejection of rehabilitation of the convict as a basic purpose of criminal justice. And it is unique, finally, in its absolute renunciation
…S. 269 (1942), and Carter v. Illinois , 329 U. S. 173 (1946), the defendants had competently waived counsel but later sought to renounce
Renee Rogers asked a coworker to start a fight with a visiting inspector so the inspector would be removed from the site. The next day Rogers persuaded the coworker not to act and arranged for extra security instead. The successful prevention of the crime under circumstances showing complete and voluntary renunciation supplies a defense to the solicitation charge.
The actor must have thwarted the success of the conspiracy, not merely withdrawn from it, under circumstances manifesting a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal purpose.
Supporting sources
The solicitor must persuade the person solicited not to commit the crime or otherwise prevent its commission under circumstances manifesting a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal purpose.
Supporting sources