Also known as: renunciation defences · renunciation · renunciation doctrine
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
An affirmative defense to liability for attempt, conspiracy, or solicitation that excuses the defendant when the actor abandons the criminal effort or prevents its commission under circumstances manifesting a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal purpose. Renunciation is not voluntary if motivated by increased probability of detection or apprehension or by circumstances making the crime more difficult. Renunciation is not complete if motivated by a decision to postpone the conduct or transfer the effort to a similar objective.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Raymond Ramos, a mechanic, cut the brake lines on a customer's car intending her death in a crash. An hour later he installed new lines and restored the brakes before any harm occurred. Because he abandoned the effort and prevented commission under circumstances showing complete and voluntary renunciation, the defense applies to the attempt charge.
Rosalind Reed offered cash to a stagehand to start a fight with a critic at a music festival so security would eject the critic. The next morning she told the stagehand to forget the plan. Because common law treats the solicitation as complete upon the request, the later withdrawal provides no defense.
Rhea Reynolds planted a false fuse in a warehouse intending arson for insurance. Hours later she removed the fuse and notified the owner before any ignition. Because she abandoned the effort and prevented commission under circumstances showing complete and voluntary renunciation, the defense applies to the attempt charge.
Rebecca Ross agreed with a colleague to falsify test data so substandard aircraft panels could ship. After a near-miss incident she uploaded accurate failing results, alerted the customer, and halted the shipment. Because she thwarted the conspiracy under circumstances manifesting complete and voluntary renunciation, the defense applies.
Roland Rhodes asked a coworker to delete database entries so defective parts could ship. Hours later he persuaded the coworker not to act and the parts were never shipped. Because he persuaded the solicited person not to commit the crime under circumstances manifesting complete and voluntary renunciation, the defense applies.
Ruby Rivera agreed with two others to falsify records for a fraudulent loan. Days later she destroyed the false documents, warned the lender, and caused the scheme to collapse. Because she thwarted the conspiracy under circumstances manifesting complete and voluntary renunciation, the defense applies.
Under the Model Penal Code the defense applies even after an overt act if the actor abandons the effort or prevents commission under circumstances manifesting complete and voluntary renunciation. The defense is unavailable if the renunciation is motivated by increased risk of detection or by a decision to postpone the crime.
At common law once the defendant has made a solicitation subsequent withdrawal or renunciation ordinarily does not constitute a defense to the charge of solicitation. The offense is complete upon the request with specific intent that the crime be committed.
…principled task, and the momentary political convenience often attendant upon their failure to do so, argue against a complete renunciation of the judicial role. Although it is the obligation of all officers of the Government to respect the constitutional design, see Public Citizen v. Department of Justice , 491 U. S. 440, 466…
…rejection of rehabilitation of the convict as a basic purpose of criminal justice. And it is unique, finally, in its absolute renunciation
…other that it no longer intends to honor their contract. "[W]here the contract is renounced before performance is due, and the renunciation
…powers. The right may be voluntarily relinquished or abandoned either by express language or by language and conduct that show a renunciation of citizenship. Under these principles, this petitioner has not lost his citizenship. Desertion in wartime, though it may merit the ultimate penalty, does not necessarily signify…
…(Penal Law § 25.00 [2]; People v. Butts , 72 NY2d 746, 749, n 1). At trial, however, defendant never sought to present a renunciation defense
The actor must thwart the success of the conspiracy under circumstances manifesting a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal purpose. Mere notice of withdrawal without thwarting the conspiracy is insufficient under the Model Penal Code provision.
Under the Model Penal Code it is an affirmative defense that the actor after soliciting another persuaded the person not to commit the crime under circumstances manifesting complete and voluntary renunciation. The persuasion must be effective and the renunciation must be both complete and voluntary.
Renunciation is not voluntary if motivated in whole or in part by circumstances that increase the probability of detection or apprehension or that make accomplishment of the criminal purpose more difficult. A decision to postpone the conduct or transfer the effort to a similar objective also renders the renunciation incomplete.