/SPRING-ing and SHIFT-ing ek-SEK-yoo-tor-ee IN-tuh-ress/·phrase
Also known as:springing executory interest · shifting executory interest · springing executory interests · shifting executory interests · executory interests
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A future interest created in a transferee that divests a prior estate rather than awaiting its natural termination. Springing executory interests divest an interest retained by the grantor. Shifting executory interests divest an interest held by another grantee.
Sources & Authorities
How it applies
Common Examples
2
Conveyance Before Issue Birth
Scott Summers holds a fee simple conditional under his uncle's deed with an executory interest in favor of his cousin Timothy if Scott dies without surviving issue. Before any children are born, Scott conveys the parcel in fee simple absolute language to Sterling Dynamics. Sterling Dynamics records the deed and begins development. Timothy's executory interest remains superior to any interest Sterling Dynamics acquired.
Alternative Contingencies Dispute
A grantor structures a conveyance creating an executory interest that may vest on one of two alternative events. One contingency satisfies the rule against perpetuities while the other does not. The court upholds the valid contingency and enforces the executory interest that divests the prior estate upon that event.
Put it into practice
Test Yourself
10
Practice Questions5
· 9 sources
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Restatements
Study Supplements
Williams v. Watt668 P.2d 620, 627 (Wyo. 1983)
Common questions
Frequently Asked
3
How do springing and shifting executory interests differ from remainders?+
Remainders take effect upon the natural expiration of a prior estate. Executory interests instead divest a prior interest that has already vested. Springing executory interests cut short an interest retained by the grantor. Shifting executory interests cut short an interest held by another grantee.
Supporting sources
Are springing and shifting executory interests subject to the rule against perpetuities?+
Yes. These interests are created in transferees and may vest too remotely. They are therefore subject to the rule unless an exemption applies. Retained interests such as possibilities of reverter are exempt, but executory interests in third parties are not.
Supporting sources
What happens when a holder of a fee simple conditional conveys the land before issue is born?+
The conveyance creates interests equivalent to those a fee simple absolute owner could create. All such interests remain subordinate to any valid executory interest limited after the conditional fee. The executory interest therefore retains priority even after the conveyance.
Supporting sources
Real PropertyOwnership of real property · Special problemsUBEIntermediate