In October 1977 Dr. Athalie Doris Joy filed a shareholder derivative suit in the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut on behalf of Connecticut Financial Services Corporation, later Citytrust Bancorp, Inc., against its wholly owned banking subsidiary Citytrust and its officers and directors. The complaint asserted common-law claims for breach of fiduciary duty and violations of the National Bank Act arising from a series of loans made by Citytrust to the Katz Corporation to finance construction of an office building in Norwalk, Connecticut, and sought recovery of approximately six million dollars.
The underlying transactions began in 1967 when Citytrust entered a twenty-year lease for space in the planned building. In January 1971 Katz obtained a four-million-dollar construction mortgage in which Citytrust participated for five hundred thousand dollars while Chase Manhattan Bank supplied the remainder. Unsecured advances from Citytrust to Katz grew steadily, reaching nine hundred thousand dollars by December 1972 and one million eight hundred forty thousand dollars by June 1973. In November 1973 Citytrust obtained a blanket second mortgage on the building and other Katz properties. By April 1975 Citytrust had extended more than two million six hundred thousand dollars in loans and, as a condition of refinancing arranged with Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, assumed a thirty-year master lease guaranteeing the six-million-dollar Lincoln loan.
National Bank Examiners classified portions of the Katz debt as doubtful in 1975 and substandard earlier. On August 18, 1976 the Citytrust board authorized additional loans that caused the total indebtedness to exceed the ten-percent statutory limit, after which Citytrust charged off two million dollars. In June 1977 the Katz partnership conveyed title to the building to Citytrust in exchange for releases, and Citytrust assumed the six-million-dollar Lincoln mortgage. Second Nutmeg Financial later purchased the building but subsequently defaulted, returning ownership to Citytrust.
After the Supreme Court decided Burks v. Lasker, the boards of Citytrust and its parent created a Special Litigation Committee consisting of two newly elected outside directors, Marion S. Kellogg and Ernest C. Trefz. The Committee retained independent counsel, investigated for nine months, and issued a report recommending dismissal as to twenty-three outside defendants and possible settlement with seven inside defendants. The district court permitted limited discovery on the Committee's bona fides, placed the report under seal, granted summary judgment for the twenty-three outside defendants, and Joy appealed both the judgment and the sealing order to the Second Circuit.
View case