Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A standard or condition that precludes a particular legal outcome, remedy, or action because it would be unfair or unsuitable under the circumstances.
Sources & Authorities
How it applies
Common Examples
6
Negligent Use of Defective Tool
Umar Usmani, a contractor, assigns an untrained worker to operate a crane with a known hydraulic leak. The worker loses control and damages nearby property. The court finds the assignment created an unreasonable risk because Usmani knew or should have known the instrumentality was inappropriate for the task.
Will Attempting to Devise Joint Tenancy Property
Uma Underwood executes a will leaving her jointly held home to a friend while divorce proceedings are pending. She dies before the divorce is final. The court holds that the will cannot override the right of survivorship, and equity will not impose a constructive trust absent unjust enrichment.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Cases
Statutes
Federal Rules
Uniform Acts
Model Codes
Restatements
Casebooks
Ulric Unger, a lawyer, agrees to represent a neighborhood coalition challenging library closures for a nominal fee far below his standard rate. The coalition explains that full rates would force cuts to its literacy programs. Unger properly counts the matter as qualifying pro bono service because payment of standard fees would be otherwise inappropriate.
Forwarding Petition to Proper Tribunal
Ugo Uberti files a child-support petition in State A family court. The court determines it lacks jurisdiction under the uniform act and forwards the documents to the appropriate tribunal in State B while notifying Ugo of the transfer.
Injunction Despite Jury-Trial Issues
Unity Capital seeks an injunction to stop a neighboring factory from emitting pollutants that damage its property. The defendant argues that factual disputes require a jury trial. The court grants the injunction because the need for a jury does not render the remedy inappropriate.
Application of Federal Labor Standards to State Activity
Ulysses Maritime, a state-owned port authority, sells surplus cargo-handling services to private shippers. Federal regulators apply the Fair Labor Standards Act overtime rules to its employees. The court upholds the application because states are protected from inappropriate federal regulation through the political process rather than judicial limits.
Common questions
Frequently Asked
3
When does a court find that applying a particular rule or remedy would be unjust or inappropriate?+
A court makes that finding when the outcome would produce unfairness, such as when an instrumentality creates an unreasonable risk, when a will attempts to override survivorship rights without unjust enrichment, or when a tribunal lacks jurisdiction under a uniform act.
Supporting sources
How does the phrase function in pro bono service rules?+
It permits a lawyer to count reduced-fee work for qualifying organizations when full payment would significantly deplete the organization's resources or would otherwise be inappropriate given the client's mission and finances.
Supporting sources
Does the need for a jury trial make an injunction inappropriate in tort cases?+
No. The necessity or advisability of a jury trial on factual issues does not render an injunction inappropriate as a remedy for tort.
Supporting sources
326 U.S. 310 (1945)Civil Procedure
…there was not sufficient notice of the suit, or that the suit was so unrelated to those activities as to make the agent an inappropriate vehicle for communicating the notice. It is enough that appellant has established such contacts with the state that the particular form of substituted service adopted there gives reasonable…