Concept
The Immunity Baseline
Has the state waived immunity or has Congress validly abrogated it?
Waiver and Abrogation of Immunity
The Immunity Baseline
Read literally, the Eleventh Amendment is a narrow provision. It says that the judicial power of the United States "shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law or equity, commenced or prosecuted against one of the United States by Citizens of another State, or by Citizens or Subjects of any Foreign State."1 Two kinds of plaintiff appear in that sentence, and they are the two who had reached federal court through the Citizen-State and Alien-State Diversity Clauses of Article III, § 2. The Amendment can therefore be read as closing those two doors and leaving the others open, including the door for suits arising under federal law.2 On that reading, a plaintiff could still sue a state in federal court to redress a violation of federal law, and a state's own citizen would find nothing in the text to stop her. The Court has never read the Amendment that way, and the distance between the words and the doctrine is the subject of this unit.
The Amendment's history points to the premise the Court reads into it. The Amendment overruled Chisholm v. Georgia two years after that decision and narrowed federal jurisdiction so that a state could no longer be sued in federal court simply because the plaintiff was a citizen of another state or of a foreign country.3 Hamilton had stated the underlying premise in The Federalist No. 81: "It is inherent in the nature of sovereignty not to be amenable to the suit of an individual without its consent." Unless the convention's plan surrendered that immunity, he wrote, it would remain with the states.4
The turning point came in 1890. In Hans v. Louisiana, a Louisiana plaintiff sued the State of Louisiana in federal court, alleging that the state had violated the Contracts Clause of Article I, § 10 by reneging on bonds it had issued during Reconstruction. The plaintiff was not a citizen of another state, and because his claim arose under the Constitution, he came in through the federal-question door rather than either door the Amendment closes. The Court dismissed the action anyway.5
The Court's modern account explains why. In Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Florida, it described the presupposition first observed in Hans as having two parts: each state is a sovereign entity in our federal system, and it is "inherent in the nature of sovereignty not to be amenable to the suit of an individual without its consent."6 Hans itself had held that federal jurisdiction over suits against unconsenting states "was not contemplated by the Constitution when establishing the judicial power of the United States."7
Alden v. Maine draws the consequence for the familiar label. Courts often call this protection "Eleventh Amendment immunity," but the phrase is "convenient shorthand but something of a misnomer," because the immunity "neither derives from, nor is limited by, the terms of the Eleventh Amendment." It is instead a fundamental aspect of the sovereignty the states enjoyed before ratification and retain today, except as altered by the plan of the Convention or certain constitutional Amendments.8 That is why the immunity outruns the text. Absent the state's consent, it bars each of the following suits, though the Amendment's words mention none of them:
- A suit by the state's own citizen, although the text names only citizens of another state and foreign citizens or subjects.9
- A suit arising under federal law, although the Amendment was born of a diversity dispute.10
- A suit in admiralty, which the text does not address.11
- A suit by a foreign state, although the text speaks only of individual plaintiffs.12
The immunity belongs to the state and its arms, not to every governmental body within the state. A city or a county is not the state for this purpose, while an "arm of the state" receives the immunity. Deciding whether a state university or a department of public health counts as an arm can be complex and often turns on the entity's treatment under state law.13
Suits against state officers follow a separate path under Ex parte Young, which permits suits against state officers for injunctive or declaratory relief and which this chapter takes up later.14
Everything that follows builds on one working rule: a private suit against a nonconsenting state in federal court is barred unless the state has waived its immunity or Congress has validly abrogated it. Waiver comes first, because the immunity is the state's to give up. Abrogation then requires two showings: Congress must have unequivocally expressed its intent to abrogate, and it must have acted pursuant to a valid exercise of power.15 The same sovereignty principle also keeps a state from being forced to answer as a defendant in its own courts, so the analysis does not end when a plaintiff leaves federal court.16