Concept
Why Standing Exists
Standing
Article III Standing
Why Standing Exists
Federal courts may decide only “cases” and “controversies,” and standing is the doctrine that tests whether a particular plaintiff has brought one. Congress cannot require the Court to render opinions in matters that are not cases or controversies, so each plaintiff must show the “personal stake in the outcome of the controversy” that Article III demands. In Buckley v. Valeo the Court put that question first, before it reached the merits.1
The requirement has teeth. Injury in fact is a “hard floor of Article III jurisdiction” and an “irreducible constitutional minimum,” not merely a pleading requirement.2 The test asks about the circumstances of the person who sued, and it does not ask whether that person would win.3
The first suit presents a case or controversy. Jean and the manufacturer are adverse parties in an actual dispute over their legal rights and obligations, because she seeks to establish the very liability the manufacturer resists, and the court can provide effective relief by awarding compensatory damages if liability is established.4 The second suit presents none. Jean no longer asks for compensation for an injury of her own; she asks for better law, and the elements of a case or controversy are lacking.5
Two structural concerns explain why the Court insists on this. The first is separation of powers: Article III standing “serves to prevent the judicial process from being used to usurp the powers of the political branches” and confines the federal courts to a properly judicial role.6 A court that heard every citizen who disliked a statute or an enforcement decision would be reviewing the other branches on demand. The second is the Court's long-standing restraint in constitutional cases. It refrains from passing on the constitutionality of an act of Congress unless obliged to do so in the proper performance of its judicial function, and then only “when the question is raised by a party whose interests entitle him to raise it.”7
Because the requirement is constitutional, nobody can waive it. Congress cannot erase Article III's standing requirements by “statutorily granting the right to sue to a plaintiff who would not otherwise have standing.”8 The litigants cannot waive it either. The absence of standing deprives the district court of jurisdiction, and the issue stays open throughout the litigation, so a party may raise it for the first time on appeal.9 The court of appeals may raise it on its own, and a party's standing “must exist at all times.”10 A defendant who says nothing at trial and loses can therefore still obtain dismissal on appeal.
The plaintiff must have (1) suffered an injury in fact, (2) that is fairly traceable to the challenged conduct of the defendant, and (3) that is likely to be redressed by a favorable judicial decision.11 The sections that follow take each element in turn, then the special rules on generalized grievances, appeals, third-party rights, and associations. The rest of this section covers three rules that apply across all of them: who carries the burden, how standing is measured claim by claim, and which courts the doctrine binds.
The Plaintiff's Burden
The plaintiff, as the party invoking federal jurisdiction, bears the burden of establishing each element of standing.13 The burden grows heavier as the case advances. At the pleading stage the plaintiff must “clearly . . . allege facts demonstrating” each element.14 At summary judgment, specific facts must be adduced by sworn testimony, and a generalized allegation of injury that would survive a challenge on the pleadings will not carry the plaintiff that far.15
Two decisions issued very close in time show the procedural posture doing the work. Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council granted standing and Lujan denied it, yet the distinction “rests in law rather than chronology.” Lujan reached the Court after summary judgment, where specific facts had to be adduced by sworn testimony, whereas a challenge to a generalized allegation of injury at the pleading stage would have been unsuccessful.16 On an exam, identify the posture before judging the plaintiff's facts, because an allegation that carries a complaint may not carry a summary-judgment record.
Claim-by-Claim Standing
A plaintiff must satisfy standing separately for each claim asserted. In DaimlerChrysler Corp. v. Cuno the Court rejected a theory of “ancillary standing,” so standing on one claim does not carry the others along with it.18 The same plaintiff may thus have standing for one form of relief and lack it for another. A sufficient past injury can give a plaintiff standing to seek damages, while any threatened future injury may be too speculative or remote to support standing for prospective injunctive relief. Plaintiffs who seek both can have standing for both, but they must show it for each.19
City of Los Angeles v. Lyons is the standard illustration: “[P]ast exposure to illegal conduct does not in itself show a present case or controversy regarding injunctive relief.”20 An exam stem that describes a plaintiff hurt once who now asks a court to stop the practice is testing this rule. The plaintiff keeps the damages claim, but must separately show that future injury is likely enough to support an injunction. If the future injury is speculative, the court hears one claim and dismisses the other for want of standing.
Federal Courts Only
Standing limits only the federal courts. Justiciability is a body of judicially created doctrines that define and limit the circumstances under which an Article III federal court may exercise its constitutional authority. Some of those doctrines come from the case-or-controversy requirement itself and some from prudential views about the proper role of the federal judiciary.22 A state court is not an Article III court, so these limits do not govern what it may hear. In federal court, Jean the consumer advocate has no case or controversy, and whether a state court would hear her depends on state law.23
The difference matters most on removal. When a case is removed from state to federal court, the party invoking federal jurisdiction is the defendant, and the defendant has the initial burden of showing that the case meets federal justiciability requirements.24 A removed case that fails those requirements cannot stay in federal court, and if the state's own rules permit the suit, it returns to state court.25