Concept
The Live Controversy Requirement
Mootness
Mootness and Its Exceptions
The Live Controversy Requirement
A federal court may decide only a live controversy, and a case that stops being one is moot. When a judicial decision could have no practical legal effect because the issues that produced it have been resolved or have disappeared, the case is moot.1 Article III permits courts to decide actual cases and controversies and nothing else.2 A justiciable controversy must be definite and concrete, must touch the legal relations of parties with adverse legal interests, and must be real and substantial enough to admit of specific relief through a decree of a conclusive character. It cannot be a request for an opinion advising what the law would be on a hypothetical state of facts.3 Mootness applies that definition across time: a dispute that met every one of those terms on the day of filing can stop meeting them later.
The requirement therefore holds at every stage of the case. The Court has described the usual rule as one "that an actual controversy must exist at all stages of appellate or certiorari review, and not simply at the date the action is initiated".4 The starting point, the Court has explained, is that federal courts "are without power to decide questions that cannot affect the rights of litigants in the case before them".5 A case that began live can lose its controversy in several ways:
- The law changes while the case is pending.
- The defendant pays what it owed and no longer wishes to appeal, even though the plaintiff still wants a higher court's ruling.
- The allegedly wrongful behavior ends and could not reasonably be expected to recur.
- The challenged statute can no longer affect the litigant, as when a plaintiff challenging a law about minors passes out of the covered age bracket, or dies.6
A change in the plaintiff's circumstances does not always end the case, though. The plaintiff in Roe v. Wade challenged the Texas ban on abortion, but her pregnancy was over by the time the suit reached the Supreme Court. The Court nonetheless did not treat the case as moot, relying on an exception examined later in this chapter.7 Nor may a defendant manufacture mootness at the last minute. A voluntary cessation that comes only after the Court has agreed to review a case is inherently suspect, because "postcertiorari maneuvers designed to insulate a decision from review by this Court must be viewed with a critical eye".8
The requirement exists because a ruling in a dead case would be advisory. Mootness is primarily an expression of the no-advisory-opinions principle9, and the reasons for refusing advisory opinions explain why the Court insists on a live dispute:
- An advisory ruling may not bind the parties. If they need not accept the Court's advice, its power erodes.10
- It undercuts the adversary system. Suits for advisory opinions are more likely to be collusive, and parties anxious for a particular answer are less likely to brief every relevant issue.11
- It is a greater power than the reluctant judicial review that Marbury v. Madison justified, because it multiplies the occasions on which unelected judges can intrude on the democratic process by freezing their views into constitutional law, divorced from any concrete case. The framers rejected giving Article III judges that power.12
The Court recognized the limit early. In 1793 Secretary of State Jefferson submitted 29 questions on international law, neutrality, and the French and British treaties. In its reply to President Washington, the Court said that the separation of powers and its position as a court of last resort argued against answering them.13 A moot case presents the same difficulty in a different setting: the legal question may be genuine and important, but the parties' rights no longer depend on the answer.
Mootness also belongs to a family of doctrines. Standing, ripeness, and mootness are, in the words of Poe v. Ullman, several manifestations, each with its own varied application, of one conception: federal judicial power to strike down legislation is exercised only at the instance of someone immediately harmed, or immediately threatened with harm, by the challenged action.14 Mootness asks whether that harm has survived to the present.
Mootness also has a wrinkle that explains much of what follows in this chapter. The Court has sometimes called it a constitutional limitation, on the ground that a case or controversy requires a present, flesh-and-blood dispute the courts can resolve.15 At other times it has relaxed the rule so that it will not be so rigid as to prevent review of important constitutional issues.16 The better view is that mootness rests partly on the constitutional limit of judicial power to cases and controversies and partly on a rule of self-restraint, and the Court does not always say which is doing the work.17 The Supreme Court's mootness cases are not easily rationalized.18
The mixed character creates a theoretical puzzle. The exceptions the Court recognizes rest on pragmatic concerns, such as conserving judicial resources, deterring bad behavior, and fairness to individuals, yet those concerns cannot expand a limit that Article III itself imposes.19 On an exam you need not resolve that puzzle. State the Article III baseline and be ready to apply the exceptions covered later.
Because mootness is a rule of subject matter jurisdiction20, it limits the court's power and not merely the parties' rights. Two litigants who both want a ruling therefore cannot revive a case that events have emptied, because agreement cannot supply a controversy that has disappeared.
Students most often go wrong by treating the filing date as the only date that matters. A pair of cases shows why that fails.
Both plaintiffs were injured when they filed, so injury at the outset cannot separate them. What separates them is whether a decree entered today could still change the legal relationship between the parties. That question, whether any meaningful relief remains, becomes the working test in a later section of this chapter.