Concept
A Self-Executing Ban
Nineteenth Amendment enforcement power
A Self-Executing Ban
The Nineteenth Amendment needs no statute to take effect. Its first sentence is a flat prohibition: the right of citizens to vote “shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex.” Its second sentence gives Congress “power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation,” and a careless reader may take that grant for a condition, as though the prohibition lay dormant until Congress woke it.1 The text supports no such reading. The enforcement clause gives the courts a partner; the prohibition binds the United States and every State of its own force.
A guarantee that waited on Congress would leave every woman's claim hostage to the legislative calendar. The Amendment avoids that result. A court hearing the first lawsuit needs only the Amendment and the challenged rule, and it asks one question: does the rule deny or abridge the vote on account of sex? If it does, the rule yields.2 Congress's enforcement power then adds remedies to a right that already exists; it does not create the right.3
The Supreme Court first examined the Amendment in detail in Leser v. Garnett, a challenge to its validity. Qualified Maryland voters sued in state court to strike certain women from the list of qualified voters, arguing that Maryland's constitution limited suffrage to men and that the Nineteenth Amendment had not been validly ratified. The state court took jurisdiction, and the state's Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment dismissing the petition.4 The Supreme Court upheld the Amendment and described it as “in character and phraseology precisely similar to the Fifteenth.”5 That description unlocks the rest of the doctrine.
Fifteen years later, Breedlove v. Suttles stated the consequence outright: the Amendment “applies to men and women alike and by its own force supersedes inconsistent measures, whether federal or state.”6 The Court drew that sentence from Leser.7 The words “by its own force” carry the self-executing rule, and the words “federal or state” mark how far it reaches. Harper v. Virginia Board of Elections later overruled Breedlove, so the poll-tax holding is gone.8 A modern opinion nonetheless relies on its account of how the Amendment operates, reading Leser and Breedlove together to mean that the Nineteenth, like the Fifteenth, is an absolute and self-enforcing prohibition on discriminatory classifications in voting.9
The Fifteenth Amendment decisions show that operation at work. The Nineteenth is a close copy of the Fifteenth, with sex substituted for race, color, or previous condition of servitude, and the Supreme Court has said the Fifteenth's declaration “has always been treated as self-executing and has repeatedly been construed, without further legislative specification, to invalidate state voting qualifications or procedures which are discriminatory on their face or in practice.”10 In Neal v. Delaware the Court held that the prohibition could “remove . . . or render inoperative” a suffrage provision in a state constitution that refers to race, even with no implementing legislation from Congress. In Guinn v. United States it invalidated an Oklahoma amendment that created a literacy test but exempted anyone who had been eligible to vote before the Amendment's ratification.11 These decisions supply the template for the Nineteenth. A clause confining the vote to men falls to an ordinary lawsuit, and a facially neutral device built to the same end invites the same attack.
The Fifteenth Amendment's enforcement clause also shows what such a clause adds, because it uses the words the Nineteenth later borrowed: “Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.” The Court read that authorization to make Congress chiefly responsible for implementing the rights the first section creates: “Some legislation is contemplated to make the [Civil War] amendments fully effective.” Accordingly, in addition to the courts, Congress has full remedial powers to effectuate the prohibition.12 The two powers work side by side, and the courts' power does not wait on Congress's. A State therefore cannot defend a sex-based rule by pointing out that Congress never legislated.
A bar-exam stem that mentions in passing that Congress never enacted an implementing statute is testing exactly this point.
The ban has a limit built into its words: it displaces a measure only when the measure denies or abridges the vote on account of sex. In Breedlove the challenged law was a poll tax, with an exception for nonvoting women, that had to be paid before registration. The Court held that requiring payment before registration neither denied nor abridged the right to vote on account of sex. It added that the Amendment's purpose “is not to regulate the levy or collection of taxes,” and it found it fanciful to call the tax a disguise for denying men the vote on account of their sex.14 A neutral payment rule of that kind survived the Nineteenth Amendment, and Harper later overruled the decision.15 Self-execution settles how the prohibition operates; what it covers is the subject of the next section.