Concept
Inducement and Voidability
Undue influence
Inducement and Voidability
Section 177(2) of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts adds two requirements to the persuasion that subsection (1) describes: the persuasion must have induced the victim's manifestation of assent, and the resulting contract is voidable by the victim.1 Subsection (1) defined the wrong as unfair persuasion of a party who is dominated by the persuader, or who by virtue of their relationship is justified in assuming that the persuader will not act inconsistently with his welfare.2 Subsection (2) says when that wrong matters to a particular contract and what the victim may do about it.
The two questions arise in order. Cause comes first, because only a contract whose assent was induced reaches the question of remedy. The first subsection below shows how a court decides whether the persuasion induced the assent. The second explains what it means for the contract to be voidable rather than void.
Inducing the Assent
The operative word in § 177(2) is induced. Unfair persuasion makes a contract avoidable only if it produced the victim's assent, so the court asks whether, from the entire context, the victim's will was overborne, leading the victim to do, or to forgo, what the victim would not have done, or would have done, if left to act freely.3
Not every influence qualifies. Undue influence is persuasion that tends to be coercive, persuasion that overcomes the will without convincing the judgment. Its hallmark is high pressure that works on mental, moral, or emotional weakness until it approaches the boundaries of coercion, which is why courts have called it overpersuasion.4 To be unlawful, an influence must overcome the free will and eliminate unconstrained action.5 Persuasion that convinces the judgment does neither. A person who weighs the arguments, takes advice, and concludes that the bargain is a good one has made a choice, however many of the reasons came from someone else.
The court looks at what the persuasion did to the victim's will, not at the form it took. Any species of coercion, whether physical, mental, or moral, that subverts the sound judgment and genuine desire of the individual is enough, and the nature, extent, or degree of the means is inconsequential so long as it substitutes the dominating purpose of another for the free expression of the signer's wishes.6 The persuader need not have lied, because a person's will may be overborne without misrepresentation.7 Nor need the persuader have made a wrongful threat, which distinguishes undue influence from duress.8
Inducement happens inside the victim's decision, and direct evidence of undue influence is rarely obtainable. A court therefore decides the question by inference from the totality of the facts and circumstances.9 The inference draws on a recognizable pattern, which Odorizzi v. Bloomfield School District catalogued. The pattern usually involves several of these elements:10
- discussion of the transaction at an unusual or inappropriate time;
- consummation of the transaction in an unusual place;
- an insistent demand that the business be finished at once;
- extreme emphasis on the untoward consequences of delay;
- the use of multiple persuaders by the dominant side against a single servient party;
- absence of third-party advisers to the servient party; and
- statements that there is no time to consult financial advisers or attorneys.
When a number of these elements are present at once, the persuasion may be characterized as excessive.11 The list guides the inference; it does not replace the question whether the whole context shows an overborne will.12 One shortcut deserves a mention here and fuller treatment later: once a confidential relationship and a transaction benefiting the person in whom trust is reposed are shown, the burden falls on the benefited party to show that the transaction was not procured by undue influence.13
Section 177(2) speaks of undue influence by 'the other party,' so the inquiry runs between the victim and the person across the bargaining table. When the persuader instead induces the victim to contract with a third party, such as a bank lending money, the contract cannot be avoided unless that third party is aware of the undue influence. A third party without that awareness stands in the position of a bona fide purchaser for value.14 A later section develops that rule.
Voidability and Ratification
Section 177(2) makes the contract voidable, not void. A voidable contract is one in which a party has the power either to elect to avoid the legal relations the contract created or, by ratification, to extinguish the power of avoidance, and that power can belong to minors and to persons induced to contract by undue influence, fraud, mistake, or duress.16 Until the victim chooses, the contract stands.
The choice belongs to the victim alone. Only the protected party may raise the defense, and that party may choose to enforce a favorable contract.17 The allocation follows from whom the doctrine protects. A victim may find the bargain advantageous despite how it came about, and a rule that made the contract void would deny the victim that choice while handing the party who applied the pressure an exit through his own overreaching.
Equity supplied the remedy. Courts of equity insisted that no advantage be gained through gross unfairness in bargaining, and they allowed the victim of overreaching to rescind or avoid the contract. Now that law and equity have merged, any court in which contract actions are brought can avoid a contract without requiring a separate proceeding for rescission.18 For undue influence, the equitable remedy was cancellation of the contaminated instrument, avoidance of the transaction, and restoration of the status quo ante. Where law and equity are merged and the victim wants only a money judgment, a quasi-contractual action may be brought at law.19
The remedy is avoidance, not damages, because undue influence is not a tort; the authorities know of no case treating it as one.20 Howe v. Palmer shows the separation. A jury found that a 2000 deed from Howe to the Palmers was the product of undue influence and, as a separate finding, that the Palmers had intentionally inflicted emotional distress on him.21 The first finding went to the validity of the deed, and the second named a tort.
Restoration is the point of avoidance: the victim gets back what the contract took. Odorizzi's teacher, Don, shows what that can mean in practice. After the criminal charges against him were dismissed in July 1964, he turned his attention to getting his teaching job back.22
Restoration runs in both directions. When a contract is avoided based on a defense, each party has a restitution claim for any benefit previously conferred on the other.23 The settlement in Gengaro v. City of New Haven shows what each side may have to account for in an exchange of that kind. A city employee, suspended pending an investigation of sexual-harassment allegations, agreed to resign in exchange for $7,500, payment of accrued vacation and sick leave, and the city's promise not to oppose his unemployment claim.24 A loan from a lawyer to a client illustrates the same limit. Such a loan is presumptively voidable, and if the presumption is not rebutted, the client repays only the principal and the cost of the money to the lawyer.25
The victim holds a second option alongside avoidance. The victim may ratify the contract, and ratification extinguishes the power of avoidance.26 Both options are the victim's. Once the victim ratifies, the contract can no longer be avoided on this ground, and the party who applied the pressure can neither avoid it nor ratify on the victim's behalf.