Concept
Existing and Identified Goods
Identification of goods
Existing and Identified Goods
Before any interest in goods can pass, the goods must be both existing and identified. Section 2-105(2) says so directly: goods that lack either quality are “future” goods, and a purported present sale of future goods operates as a contract to sell.1 The two conditions do separate work. Goods exist when they have a physical reality, which excludes whatever the seller hopes to grow, build, or acquire later. Goods are identified when the contract has attached to particular items, so that someone could point and say these are the ones the deal concerns. A present transfer needs something to transfer, and goods that are unbuilt, or that nobody has singled out, give an interest nothing to rest on. The statute therefore reads the words of a present sale as a promise about a later transfer, which is what a contract to sell is.
The question arises because contracts usually speak in general terms. A buyer orders five hundred bushels of No. 2 wheat or twelve office chairs, and the contract names a kind of goods and a quantity without pointing at any particular bushel or chair. Many of Article 2's consequences wait until that general description is tied to specific goods, because rights in goods can exist only in goods that can be located. The point also finishes a thread from earlier in the chapter: the definition of goods in § 2-105(1) measures movability at the time of identification to the contract for sale, so the timing of identification was already doing quiet work.2 Here it becomes the subject.
The subsections below take up the vocabulary of existing and future goods first, then the moment at which identification occurs, and then the Code's treatment of part interests, bulk goods, lots, and commercial units, where the answer to which goods the contract refers to is less obvious than it is for a single boat. The working test for any fact pattern is whether specific goods exist that the contract refers to. The next major section explains what follows once the answer is yes. Here the task is to learn the terms and to find the moment at which the answer changes.
Existing Versus Future Goods
The word both in § 2-105(2) does the sorting. Goods must be existing and identified before an interest in them can pass, and goods that fail either part are future goods.3 A good can fail on existence, as when a manufacturer has not yet built it, or on identification, as when it exists but the contract has not yet attached to it. The same subsection supplies the consequence: a purported present sale of future goods, or of any interest in them, operates as a contract to sell.4
Each half of the rule has its own logic. The existence-and-identification requirement follows from what it means for an interest to pass. A buyer promised a sloop that has not been built cannot point to any boat and say that an interest runs to it. The recharacterization rule answers a different problem, because contracts for goods yet to be made often use the vocabulary of present sale. Taking those words literally would force a choice between two bad results: treating the transfer as ineffective and risking no deal at all, or giving the buyer an interest in goods that nobody has made or chosen. Reading the words as a contract to sell avoids both. The promise binds the parties now, and the interest waits for the goods.
A common exam question asks whether an agreement to sell goods not yet manufactured is a transaction in goods at all.5 The instinct that loses points is to reason that, with no desk built and no sale completed, Article 2 has nothing to govern. Suppose a buyer picks a desk from a seller's catalogue, the seller must manufacture it, and delivery is estimated at six weeks. The day after signing, the seller repudiates because the model is being discontinued.6 Article 2 reaches that contract for three linked reasons. First, a contract for sale covers a contract to sell goods at a future time as well as a present sale, so the agreement to transfer the desk once it is made falls inside the Article. Second, the definition of goods measures movability at identification and not at signing, so future goods are a subset of goods and stay subject to Article 2 if they are or will be movable when identified.7 Third, § 2-610 expressly covers repudiation, which shows that the drafters meant Article 2 to govern contracts that never reach full performance, so a desk that will never be made is treated as a thing that would have been movable had it come into existence.8 Until the desk exists and is designated to the contract, the agreement is a contract to sell. It commits the seller to produce and the buyer to pay, and it passes no interest in any particular desk.
Special manufacture changes nothing. If Acme contracts with Omega to build a machine to Acme's specifications, the machine is a good, and the services that go into making it do not take the deal out of Article 2.9
The future-goods label does not sweep in everything that has not yet been built or chosen. A repudiated contract to construct a house falls outside Article 2, because it involves no movable thing and so is not a transaction in a good.10 At the other pole, a shopper who takes a coat off the rack and buys it has dealt in goods that are not future goods at all. The coat exists, and the contract attaches to it the moment the sale is made.11 Nothing remains to be made or designated, so the recharacterization rule has no work to do.
The dinghy deal shows why the rule requires both conditions. Existence alone cannot say which dinghies the buyer's interest would reach.12 How and when the designation happens is the work of the next subsection, but a decided case shows the order of events. In Media Graphics, Inc. v. Director, Division of Taxation, a New Jersey printer sold printed matter to out-of-state customers. The court reasoned that title to the printed matter could pass at some time after the goods were made. It held that title passed under § 2-401(2) when the printer completed its performance on physical delivery, which meant delivery at a New Jersey post office, so the sale was taxable by New Jersey.13 The sequence recurs throughout this chapter: goods come into being, they are identified to the contract, and only then can later events such as the passing of title occur.
Step four guards against reading the future-goods label as an exit from Article 2. The label describes the stage the deal has reached, and a contract to sell stays inside the Article as long as the thing promised will be movable once it is identified.
When Identification Occurs
Section 2-105(2) leaves the marina's four dinghies waiting to be identified, and § 2-501(1) says when the waiting ends.15 Identification of existing goods as the goods to which the contract refers can be made at any time and in any manner the parties explicitly agree, and when they have not agreed it occurs at one of three default moments that depend on the kind of goods.16 Parties negotiating price and delivery seldom specify when particular goods become the subject of the deal, so the defaults do most of the work.
The three defaults share a design. Identification answers the question which goods the contract is about, and an answer that lives only in the seller's private intention would give a buyer's interest nothing to attach to. Each default therefore ties identification to an event that other people can observe. For goods that already exist and are already singled out, the event is the making of the contract. For goods that must be made or chosen, it is an act of the seller. For crops and unborn young, which no seller can box or tag, it is a natural event. The statute lists them in that order, and so does the discussion that follows.
The first default covers goods that exist and are already identified when the parties contract, and for them identification occurs when the contract is made.17 A customer who buys a coat off the rack identifies it at that moment, because the contract refers to that coat and to no other.18 The wording looks circular, since goods that are already identified become identified when the contract is made, but the sense is plain: the goods were singled out at or before signing, so the contract attaches to them at once.19 In Draper v. Minneapolis-Moline, Inc., a dealer identified a tractor to the contract by showing it to the buyer in the store, and the last three digits of that tractor's serial number, which the buyer remembered, matched the number on the purchase agreement.20 The dealer's showing tied the contract to that tractor and no other.
This default reaches only goods that are both existing and already singled out. Goods that exist but have not been tied to the contract are future goods under § 2-105(2), and they fall to the second default.21 That default covers future goods other than the crops and unborn young described in the third: identification occurs when the goods are shipped, marked, or otherwise designated by the seller as the goods to which the contract refers.22 Identification ordinarily cannot occur until the goods are in the form they must take when tendered, so if the seller must assemble the goods before delivery, they remain unidentified until assembly is finished, even though every separate part is on hand.23 Once the seller completes the desk and designates it as the one made for the buyer's contract, that designation is the identification.24 The phrase otherwise designated reaches acts beyond shipping or labeling. In City of Louisville v. Rockwell Mfg. Co., the seller identified 1,000 parking meters to the contract by manufacturing them, packaging them, and holding them pending the buyer's delivery instructions.25
The third default hands two kinds of goods to a natural event. For unborn young to be born within twelve months after contracting, identification occurs when the young are conceived. For crops to be harvested within twelve months or the next normal harvest season after contracting, whichever is longer, it occurs when the crops are planted or otherwise become growing crops.26 A seller cannot ship, mark, or tag a calf that has not been conceived or corn that has not been planted, so the statute ties the buyer's interest to the first moment at which something identifiable exists. A farmer who contracts in February to sell the sweet corn from a particular field, to be planted in May and harvested in August, has identified nothing while the field lies bare. The crop is identified when it is planted, whether or not the farmer ever labels an ear. A crop not due for harvest until well beyond the next normal harvest season is not described in the third default. Because the second default governs future goods other than those described there, such a crop is identified only when the seller ships, marks, or otherwise designates it.27
All of this yields to explicit agreement. Section 2-501(1) lets identification be made at any time and in any manner the parties explicitly agree, and the defaults operate only when there is no such agreement.28 The override respects the way parties structure deals, since a buyer that sends its own inspectors may reasonably want identification to wait for their approval. The word explicitly limits it, because a seller's private plan about which goods will fill an order is no agreement, and the default rules then decide the timing.
Identification attaches to the goods the contract refers to even when they turn out to be nonconforming, meaning that they fail to match what the contract required. The statute gives the buyer a special property and an insurable interest through identification even though the identified goods are nonconforming and the buyer has an option to return or reject them.29 Identification and conformity answer different questions. Identification asks which goods the contract concerns, while conformity asks whether those goods are what the contract promised, and the second question arises only after the first has an answer. If conformity were a precondition, a seller who shipped the wrong goods would leave the buyer with no interest in the very goods the buyer must inspect and decide whether to reject. A special property is a buyer's interest in particular goods that can arise before title passes, and an insurable interest lets the buyer insure against their loss, so both protect the buyer during that decision.30 The later section on why identification matters develops them.
Identification made by the seller alone is less final than identification the parties agree on. Where the seller alone makes the identification, the seller may substitute other goods for those identified until default, insolvency, or notification to the buyer that the identification is final.31 A seller's designation is a unilateral act, and while the deal is running smoothly nothing yet depends on the particular goods chosen, so the statute leaves the seller free to swap a damaged unit for a sound one. Each of the three cutoffs marks a point at which the buyer's interest in particular goods has become important. Default signals that the deal has gone wrong. Insolvency sets the buyer's rights in specific goods against the claims of the seller's creditors, and a buyer holding a special property has certain rights in those goods that the seller's unsecured creditors must respect.32 A notice of finality is the seller's own assurance that the buyer may rely on these goods. The wholesaler who set aside six ovens may therefore replace them with other ovens until one of those events occurs. Identification made by agreement, or by the making of a contract for goods already singled out, is not identification by the seller alone, so the substitution right does not reach it.
Steps two and four carry most of the difficulty. A student who sees forty ovens in a warehouse and concludes that the goods exist and are therefore identified has applied the first default to goods the contract never singled out, and the right answer waits for the seller's act of designation. Nonconformity never enters the sequence, because it bears on whether the buyer must accept the goods and has no effect on whether they are identified.
Part Interests and Bulk Goods
Section 2-105(3) states in a single sentence that “There may be a sale of a part interest in existing identified goods.”34 A part interest is a fractional share of one particular thing, such as a half share in a racehorse or a one-third share in a piece of heavy equipment, and after the sale the buyer and the seller (or some other owner) hold the same item together. The provision follows how people actually hold valuable goods. Co-ownership is common, and a rule that permitted only whole-item sales would force an owner who wants a partner to transfer everything or nothing. The requirement in § 2-105(2) that goods be existing and identified describes the goods and leaves open how much of them changes hands, so a share in an identified item satisfies it.35 The same requirement still governs the item itself, so a purported present sale of a share in goods not yet made operates as a contract to sell, just as a sale of the whole would.36
Subsection (4) turns to goods sold by quantity out of a common mass. An undivided share in an identified bulk of fungible goods is sufficiently identified to be sold although the quantity of the bulk is not determined.37 A bulk is a mass of goods held together, such as the wheat in a storage bin or the oil in a tank. Goods are fungible when they are interchangeable, so that any unit is the equivalent of any other like unit, as with grain or coffee.38 An undivided share is a portion that no one has physically separated from the rest. The identification rules above ask which goods the contract refers to, and for a bulk of this kind the answer can be a share of a particular mass, with no need to point at any single bushel.
Each feature of the rule has its own reason. Dropping the demand for physical separation answers a practical problem: if no interest could pass until the buyer's portion was drawn off and set apart, the parties would pay for handling that neither side needs. Dropping the demand for a measured total rests on interchangeability. Because every unit is the equivalent of every other, the buyer's share can be fixed by a fraction or a count, and no one has to know how much the bulk holds to know what the buyer is to receive. The bulk still has to be a definite thing that the contract points to, and that requirement is where the subsection's limits come in.
Those limits are what an exam problem tests. The bulk must be identified, which means the contract must refer to a particular mass of goods, such as the coffee in a named warehouse. A contract that promises a quantity of goods the seller intends to buy later refers to no mass at all, so the goods are future goods under § 2-105(2) and the contract is one to sell.39 The goods must also be fungible, because the share concept works only when one unit can stand in for another. A seller whose stock consists of goods that differ from one another, such as paintings, cannot sell a share of that stock under this subsection, since no portion can be defined without choosing particular items.
The second sentence of § 2-105(4) describes what a buyer receives when the bulk is identified and the goods are fungible. Any agreed proportion of the bulk, or any quantity agreed upon by number, weight, or other measure, may be sold to the buyer “to the extent of the seller's interest in the bulk,” and the buyer then becomes an owner in common.40 An owner in common holds an undivided interest in the whole mass alongside the other owners, so the buyer has no claim to any particular unit and shares the whole with the seller and any other co-owners. The statute allows either method of measuring the share. A proportion such as one-quarter of the tank describes a fraction of whatever the bulk holds, and a quantity such as 10,000 gallons describes a fixed amount. Each is definite enough to identify the buyer's portion without anyone first measuring the bulk.
The phrase “to the extent of the seller's interest in the bulk” caps the buyer's interest at whatever the seller owns.41 A seller can pass only what the seller has. If the buyer's share could exceed the seller's own, the excess would come out of oil belonging to someone else, such as another owner of the same tank, who never agreed to the sale. The buyer's entitlement is therefore the lesser of the amount agreed and the amount the seller owns in the bulk. The seller's promise for any remainder is a promise to deliver goods that form no part of a bulk the seller owns, and a promise of that kind is a contract to sell goods to be acquired later.42
Steps two and five carry most of the traps. A student who sees a commodity and concludes that a buyer has an ownership share has skipped step two if the seller owns no identified stock, and one who credits the buyer with the full quantity promised has skipped step five. Step four matters for a different reason: it shows why a buyer's share can be definite before anyone counts the bulk, since a proportion or a count is enough.
Lots and Commercial Units
Section 2-105 also gives the Code two ways to decide what counts as one thing. A lot is a parcel or a single article that is the subject matter of a separate sale or delivery, whether or not it is sufficient to perform the contract.44 A commercial unit is a unit of goods that by commercial usage is a single whole for purposes of sale, and division of it materially impairs its character or value on the market or in use.45 The preceding subsection showed how a buyer can own a share of a bulk before anyone measures it out. These two definitions supply the vocabulary for the shipments and pieces that later rules count once a deal is performed in parts. Both ask what the law should treat as a single item, but they draw the line in different places, and the lot comes first because it is the simpler of the two.
The definition of a lot looks at what the parties did. A parcel or single article becomes a lot when it is the subject of a separate sale or delivery, and the closing words of the definition add that a lot may be smaller than the whole bargain.46 That qualifier matters because contracts are often performed in installments. If the only unit the law recognized were the entire contract, a late or defective shipment under a long supply deal could not be described apart from the rest. If the only unit were the individual item, nothing would describe a shipment as a shipment. A lot gives the later rules on partial deliveries and installments a unit that matches the way the parties actually divided their performance.
The definition of a commercial unit looks at the market, and its two parts each carry their own reason. The first requires that commercial usage treat the goods as a single whole for purposes of sale, which ties the concept to how the trade actually buys and sells and makes the unit whatever the relevant market regards as one piece.47 The second requires that dividing the goods materially impair their character or value on the market or in use, and this explains why usage matters: the law singles out things that lose something when they are split. The statute's own examples run from a single article such as a machine, to a set such as a suite of furniture or an assortment of sizes, to a quantity such as a bale, a gross, or a carload, and they end with any other unit treated in use or in the relevant market as a single whole.48 A commercial unit can therefore be one object, several objects, or a measured quantity, so a count of items settles nothing until the trade's usage is known.
The point of the definition shows when a delivery does not conform to the contract and the buyer wants to keep part of it. A buyer free to slice the goods wherever convenient could keep the valuable portion of a set and send the rest back. The seller would then hold a remnant, such as chairs stripped of the table they match, that the market will buy only at a discount from its share of the price. Limiting division to commercial-unit lines keeps the seller's exposure to whole units that the market can absorb. The rules on rejection and acceptance, taken up later, build on this definition and ask whether the line a buyer draws between kept and returned goods follows commercial units.
The unit in that scene comes from the market's usage. Had the trade sold bolts singly, a buyer who kept 450 and returned 50 would have divided nothing, because no whole would have been cut. The unit is fixed by what the relevant market does with the goods and by the harm division would cause, and a seller's packaging habits or the quantity written in the contract do not decide the question. A suite of furniture the trade sells only as a set is a commercial unit even though the pieces could be carried out separately, while a pile of loose, identical items that sell freely one at a time is not, however large the pile may be.
Lot and commercial unit answer different questions, and an exam problem usually calls for one of them. A lot asks which sale or delivery is under discussion, and the answer comes from what the parties did. A commercial unit asks how far the goods can be divided, and the answer comes from the market. A single lot of 500 bolts in a trade that sells them in hundreds contains five commercial units, and a single machine can be both a lot and a commercial unit. When a problem asks about a late shipment in a series, the question is about lots. When it asks whether a buyer may keep part of a delivery and reject the rest, the question is about commercial units.