Concept
Reaching the Goods Themselves
Aggrieved buyer's remedies when the seller breaches
Reaching the Goods Themselves
Section 2-711(2) opens with a condition and a connective: “Where the seller fails to deliver or repudiates the buyer may also” pursue the remedies the subsection lists.1 The word “also” tells the buyer that these remedies add to the menu in subsection (1) and do not replace it. A buyer who reaches for the goods therefore keeps its rights to cancel and to recover the price paid,2 along with the damages measures taught earlier in this chapter.
Most contract remedies are measures of money damages, and a few give non-monetary relief.3 Subsection (2) holds two of the few. Each puts the buyer within reach of the goods themselves, and each answers a problem that damages cannot always solve.
The trigger is narrower than the one that opens subsection (1). That subsection names four events, and only two of them, nondelivery and repudiation, open subsection (2).4 The line follows what the buyer holds. A buyer who has rightfully rejected or justifiably revoked already has possession or control of the goods, and its protection is the security interest in subsection (3).5 A buyer whose seller never delivered or repudiated has no possession or control,6 so the only way to obtain the goods is to reach them where the seller has them. Money is a poor substitute when cover is unavailable, as where the goods are unique.7
Subsection (2) gives the buyer two routes, and each has its own condition. The first allows the buyer to recover goods that have been identified to the contract, as § 2-502 provides.8 The second allows the buyer, in a proper case, to obtain specific performance or to replevy the goods under § 2-716.9 The first turns on whether particular goods were designated for this contract, and the second turns on whether the case is a proper one for a decree.
Recovering Identified Goods
The first goods-reaching remedy fits in one clause: where the seller fails to deliver or repudiates, the buyer may, “if the goods have been identified recover them as provided in this Article (Section 2-502).”10 Identification is the designation of the goods to the contract, and § 2-501 governs when it occurs.11 The remedy gives the buyer the goods and not money, and it stands beside the damages remedies of subsection (1) because subsection (2) says the buyer “may also” use it.12
Identification matters because it gives the buyer something in particular. A buyer that has paid some or all of the price has a right to recover identified goods, and that right “vests upon acquisition of a special property, which occurs upon identification of the goods to the contract.”13 Before identification, the buyer holds a contract for goods of a description and has no claim to any item. After it, the buyer holds a special property in particular goods and may reach them. Identification therefore marks the line between goods the buyer can claim and the seller’s general stock.
Identification opens the door, and the phrase “as provided in this Article (Section 2-502)” sends the buyer to that section for the conditions of use.14 A buyer that has not paid the whole price must be ready to tender the remainder to the seller.15 The right also applies in only two settings. For goods bought for personal, family, or household purposes, the buyer may recover them from a seller that repudiates or does not deliver as the contract requires. In every other case the buyer may recover them only if the seller becomes insolvent within ten days after receiving the first installment on the price.16 A buyer who proves identification but fits neither setting has no claim to the goods and falls back on the remedies in subsection (1). The full conditions are in § 2-502, and a problem that turns on them calls for that text.
Both buyers held the same contract rights against the same kind of breach, and the only difference was whether particular goods had been set aside. That difference is why identification is the first question in a goods-reaching problem. When the facts give a repudiating seller and a buyer who wants the goods and not money, ask whether particular goods were designated for this contract. If none were, § 2-502 is closed, and the buyer turns to specific performance in a proper case or to the damages remedies. If some were, the analysis moves to the conditions of § 2-502. A buyer who recovers identified goods needs no substitutes for them, and how this remedy combines with cover and the refund is taken up when the whole menu is assembled.
Specific Performance and Replevin
Section 2-711(2)(b) gives the second goods-reaching remedy: the buyer may “in a proper case obtain specific performance or replevy the goods as provided in this Article (Section 2-716).”19 The same two events, nondelivery and repudiation, open it, and it adds to the menu in subsection (1) without replacing it.20 Specific performance is a court order compelling the seller to deliver the promised goods instead of paying money for failing to deliver them, and replevin recovers the goods themselves. Section 2-716 sets the conditions for each, and the phrase that does the work here is “in a proper case.” A seller’s repudiation opens the subsection but does not by itself entitle the buyer to a decree.
The qualifier follows from the basic design of contract remedies. The usual remedy for breach is money damages that compensate the aggrieved party for the benefits that performance would have brought,21 and a decree is the exception. Cover and the market-price formula serve that design for replaceable goods. A buyer that covers recovers the difference between the cover price and the contract price,22 and a buyer that does not cover recovers the difference between the market price and the contract price. Either way the buyer ends with the goods it needed at the price it agreed to pay.
That reasoning fails when the goods cannot be replaced. If cover is unavailable, as where the goods are unique, the Code’s provisions on repudiation, buyer’s remedies, and specific performance indicate that specific performance may be available.23 Uniqueness describes irreplaceability and says nothing about price: a family keepsake may be worth little on the market and still be impossible to find anywhere else. Uniqueness is the illustration the commentary offers, and § 2-716 states the full test.
KGM Harvesting Co. v. Fresh Network shows the other side. The buyer there covered in order to fulfill its own contractual obligations to the Castellini Company, and it was awarded the damages called for in cover cases, the difference between the contract price and the cover price.24 A buyer that can protect itself that way has no need for a decree.
Students often assume that a seller’s repudiation gives the buyer a right to demand the goods. Repudiation opens subsection (2), but the buyer of replaceable goods already holds a remedy in cover or market damages, so the decree is reserved for the buyer whom money would leave short.
Timing is the second question, because a repudiation often comes well before the delivery date. Pre-Code law allowed the repudiatee to bring an immediate action for a decree of specific performance but postponed the effectiveness of the decree until the date for performance specified in the contract, and § 2-610(b) can be read the same way.25 The aggrieved buyer has immediate recourse against the repudiator, and absent unusual circumstances the decree should require performance in accordance with the contract and not at an accelerated pace.26 The buyer thus gets relief at once, and the seller owes no more than the contract demanded.
A buyer who obtains the very goods it contracted for has no substitute purchase to pay for, so the way this remedy combines with cancellation, the refund, and damages is taken up when the whole menu is assembled. A fact pattern with a repudiating seller and a buyer who wants the goods and not money calls for two questions in order. The first is whether the buyer could have replaced the goods by cover or recovered a market differential that puts it where performance would have. The second, if it could not, is when the decree should require delivery.