Concept
Public Documents and Records
Authentication and identification
Public Documents and Records
Rule 901(a) requires evidence sufficient to support a finding that an item is what its proponent claims it is.1 For public paper, Rules 902(1) through (4) let the proponent carry that burden without a foundation witness.2 Each category qualifies a writing only when a seal, an attestation, or a certification shows that some public officer has paid attention to the document’s genuineness, and that official attention does the work a witness would otherwise do.3 The law has long treated the seal or signature of certain officers as sufficient evidence, by itself, of the genuineness of the certificate that carries it, perhaps on the assumption that forgery is difficult.4
The categories ask for more vouching as the offered paper moves away from a sealed original. A sealed and signed original needs nothing further. An unsealed original needs a sealed certificate from a second officer. A document from abroad needs a final certification by an official the rule names. A copy needs a certificate from the person who keeps the original, or one in a form the rule accepts.
Self-authentication has the same limits in every category. It means only that the document can be admitted and considered by the jury; the opponent may still offer counterproof on authenticity and argue that the document deserves little or no weight.5 It also leaves open whether the information inside the document is accurate or usable for its truth, so a hearsay objection to statements in a self-authenticating paper survives.6
Sealed and Signed Documents
Rule 902(1) is the plainest case of official attention standing in for a foundation witness. A document qualifies when it bears two things: a seal purporting to be that of a listed governmental body, and a signature purporting to be an execution or attestation.7 The proponent tenders the paper, the judge looks at it, and no witness describes how it was made or kept. Both marks must appear. An original public record with a seal but no signature, or a signature but no seal, falls outside the category.8
The list of sealing entities reaches well beyond “federal or state.” It names the United States; any state, district, commonwealth, territory, or insular possession of the United States; the former Panama Canal Zone; the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands; a political subdivision of any of these; and a department, agency, or officer of any entity just named.9 Counties and cities are political subdivisions, and the closing clause covers a particular department or officer, so a county recorder’s seal qualifies as readily as a state’s. A private company’s seal is not on the list, and neither is a foreign government’s; foreign documents have a category of their own below.
The signature must purport to be an execution or attestation. One secondary source states the category in working terms: government documents generated by federal, state, and local agencies are self-authenticating when they bear an official seal and the signature of a public employee purporting to be an execution or attestation.10 The seal points to a government body; the signature points to the individual who signed. A forger passing off a false agency report must reproduce both.
Because the rule asks only for a seal and signature that purport to be genuine, the judge reads the exhibit and nothing else. If the face of the paper shows a seal that appears to belong to a listed entity and a signature that appears to be an execution or attestation, the document is in, and no witness confirms that the seal is real or that the officer signed. On an exam, a government paper tendered without a sponsoring witness therefore raises two questions, and the exhibit answers both: is there a seal of a listed entity, and is there a signature purporting to be an execution or attestation?
The county memo cannot borrow the next category, because an unsealed document qualifies there only when another public employee accompanies the signature with a certification under seal that the signer has the official capacity and that the signature is genuine.11 A sealed paper with no signature fails in the opposite direction, since the rule requires both marks.12 Letterhead, an agency name in a heading, and the words “public record” typed at the top are not seals.
The operator in the first example is not defenseless. It may still prove the report a forgery, and it may object that statements inside the report are hearsay.13
Unsealed but Certified Documents
Rule 902(2) governs the public document that carries a signature but no seal, and it works by moving the seal from the document to a certificate. The document qualifies when it bears the signature of an officer or employee of an entity named in Rule 902(1)(A), and another public officer who has a seal and official duties within that same entity certifies under seal, or its equivalent, that the signer has the official capacity and that the signature is genuine.15 The signer must come from the governmental bodies Rule 902(1)(A) lists, from the United States and the states through territories and political subdivisions to their departments, agencies, and officers, so an employee of a private company gains nothing here.16
Four features of the certificate matter, and each can fail alone. The certifier must be another public officer, not the signer. The certifier must hold a seal and have official duties within the signer’s own entity. The certificate must be made under seal or its equivalent. And it must say two things: that the signer has the official capacity and that the signature is genuine.17 The pairing fits the gap the missing seal leaves. A signature alone leaves open whether the signer holds a public position and whether the signature is the signer’s, and the certificate answers both.
Original public records need both a signature and a seal either way: the seal sits on the document under Rule 902(1) and on the certificate under Rule 902(2).18
The trap lies in a certificate that looks official but comes from the wrong place or says too little.
A certificate from the right officer that lacks a seal or its equivalent fails the same way. A notary’s acknowledgment does not rescue the document either: a certificate of acknowledgment lawfully executed by a notary public or another officer authorized to take acknowledgments is the basis of Rule 902(8), a separate category taken up later in this chapter, and it is not a certification under Rule 902(2)(B).20
Meeting Rule 902(2) ends the foundation question and no more. The opponent may still prove the signature a forgery or the signer a stranger to the office, and the certificate says nothing about whether the statements inside are true or usable for their truth.21
Foreign Public Documents
Rule 902(3) carries self-authentication across the border by building a chain of certifications. It reaches a document that purports to be signed or attested by a person whom a foreign country’s law authorizes to sign or attest it. The document must come with a final certification of the genuineness of the signature and official position of the signer or attester, or of any foreign official whose certificate of genuineness relates to the signature or attestation or sits in a chain of certificates relating to it.23 Three things must therefore be present: a signer with authority under foreign law, a final certification, and a certifier of a kind the rule names.
The domestic categories rest on seals an American judge can read on the page. A foreign government’s seal is not among those listed in Rule 902(1)(A), which names only the United States, its states and territories, their political subdivisions, and their departments, agencies, and officers.24 Rule 902(3) answers with certification instead. Each link in the chain vouches for the signature and official position of the official before it, and the series ends with a final certification from an official the rule names. Because the final certification may vouch for a foreign official whose certificate sits in the chain, a string of certificates can stand between the original signer and the American official at the end.
The rule also controls who may stand at the end of the chain. The final certification may be made by a secretary of a United States embassy or legation; by a consul general, vice consul, or consular agent of the United States; or by a diplomatic or consular official of the foreign country assigned or accredited to the United States.25 A certificate from anyone else, however official it looks, is not a final certification under the rule.
The rule softens the chain in one situation. If all parties have been given a reasonable opportunity to investigate the document’s authenticity and accuracy, the court may, for good cause, relax the final-certification requirement in either of two ways.26 It may order the document treated as presumptively authentic without final certification.27 Or it may allow the document to be evidenced by an attested summary, with or without final certification.28 The opportunity to investigate puts the opponent’s scrutiny in place of the officials’ advance checking, and the good-cause finding is a separate requirement. Neither step is automatic, so a missing certification does not by itself earn relief.
A document that misses every route loses the shortcut but is not barred. The proponent falls back on Rule 901, whose baseline Ghassemi v. Ghassemi states this way: the proponent must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is, and a public record that was recorded or filed as the law requires, or that comes from an office where such items are required to be kept, meets that standard.29 The fallback is a real test. Applying Rule 901 to a web page, one court held that the rule required some basis beyond a witness’s own testimony on which a reasonable juror could conclude that the page was what the proponent said it was, and that the evidence should have been excluded when no such showing was made.30
Certified Copies of Public Records
Rules 902(1) through (3) cover original documents; Rule 902(4) turns to copies. It makes self-authenticating a copy of an official record, or of a document recorded or filed in a public office as authorized by law, if the copy is certified as correct in one of the ways the rule lists.32 The rule matters because public officials seldom release originals for use in litigation, so a party who wants a government record before the court usually holds a copy.33 A copy leaves two things unproved: that the original is what it purports to be, and that the copy matches it. The custodian, who holds the original, is the person best placed to say the copy is true, and a written certificate lets the custodian say so without appearing.
The first route runs through that person. Rule 902(4)(A) accepts certification by the custodian or another person authorized to make it.34 The phrase “another person authorized” covers deputy custodians and others in the office who are authorized to copy the records in their keeping, so the proponent is not tied to the one official whose name is on the door.35 The certificate is short: the custodian states that the custodian has custody of the original record, report, entry, or recorded or filed document and that the attached copy is true and correct, and nothing more is required.36
The second route, Rule 902(4)(B), looks to the form of the certificate. It accepts a certificate that complies with Rule 902(1), (2), or (3), a federal statute, or a rule prescribed by the Supreme Court.37 The cross-references work because the certificate is itself a public document, and one that conforms to Rule 902(1), (2), or (3) is self-authenticating in its own right. A certificate carrying a seal of a listed entity and a signature purporting to be an execution or attestation, for instance, fits Rule 902(1).38 For a domestic office, nothing further is needed to prove the custody, the signer’s authority, or the genuineness of the seal or signature; foreign documents are the exception.39
The standard illustration is a recorded deed. A copy of a deed recorded in the county land records, certified as correct by the county recorder who has custody of the original, satisfies Rule 902(4)(A), and the copy comes in without a witness.40 The certificate must come from the right person, though, and a statement of correctness from someone outside the office does not qualify.
The shortcut is narrower than the phrase “public document” suggests. It reaches only official records and documents recorded or filed in a public office as authorized by law; it does not reach every paper an office happens to hold.41 A paper that merely sits in an office, such as a contractor’s draft left behind after a meeting and never submitted, is neither, and a certificate that a copy matches that paper says nothing about who wrote the original. The rule’s text also has one consequence worth remembering: a public document that qualifies in original form under Rule 902(1), (2), or (3) may not qualify as a certified copy under Rule 902(4).42
Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp. shows what happens when the shortcut fails. The plaintiffs there had not procured certified copies of the documents at issue, and the court held that this did not bar authentication, because the method of authentication in Rule 902 is not exclusive and Rule 901 remained available.43 The court added that Rule 1005 offers two ways to prove the contents of a public record: a copy certified as correct under Rule 902, or the testimony of a witness who has compared the copy with the original. Only if neither can be obtained by reasonable diligence may other evidence of the contents be given.44 A proponent who misses the shortcut therefore produces evidence sufficient to support a finding that the copy is what the proponent claims it is, often through a witness who knows where the exhibit came from.45
The certificate vouches for the copy and does no more. Being self-authenticating means only that the copy can be admitted and considered by the jury, so the opponent may still offer counterproof on authenticity and argue that the copy deserves little weight.46 Whether the contents may be used for their truth is a separate hearsay question. The hearsay exception for most official public records in Rule 803(8) does not extend to recorded or filed documents, which must find another route.47