Concept
Cross-Examining Reputation Witnesses
Reputation concerning character
Cross-Examining Reputation Witnesses
A reputation witness reports what a community says, so the opposing party cannot test the testimony by asking what the witness saw. Rule 803(21) admits "a reputation among a person's associates or in the community concerning the person's character," and what it admits is talk.1 The opponent tests talk by asking what else was said. Michelson v. United States states the bargain: the price a defendant pays for attempting to prove his good name "is to throw open the entire subject which the law has kept closed for his benefit and to make himself vulnerable where the law otherwise shields him."2
The prosecution has two ways to collect on that price. It may call contradictory witnesses to show that damaging rumors were afloat, whether or not they were well grounded, because "it is not the man that he is, but the name that he has which is put in issue." It may also cross-examine the defense witness about the contents and extent of the hearsay behind the witness's conclusion, and it may require the witness to disclose current rumors and reports even when they do not affect the witness's own view.3
Because the issue is the name, a rumor need not be true to matter. A prosecutor who asks whether the witness has heard that the accused was arrested is asking about talk. The Court approved testing the sufficiency of the witness's knowledge by asking what stories were circulating about events, such as an arrest, that people normally comment on and speculate about.4 The question puts the witness in a bind. A witness who tells the jury that the accused is well regarded claims to know where the neighborhood's talk runs. If the witness has not heard of an arrest that people would be discussing, the witness knows the talk less well than claimed. If the witness has heard of it and still reports a good name, the jury may ask how the report squares with what the neighborhood was saying. Either answer bears on the weight of the summary. Neither establishes that the arrest happened or that the accused committed the offense on trial, because the arrest matters only as one more piece of talk.
The same cross-examination polices the witness who can say only that he has "heard nothing against defendant." That answer is permitted on the assumption that, if no ill is reported of a person, his reputation must be good, even though the answer sits awkwardly beside the general demand for affirmative knowledge of the reputation. It is accepted, however, only from a witness whose knowledge of the defendant's habitat and surroundings is intimate enough that failing to hear of any relevant ill repute assures that no ugly rumors were about.5 Cross-examination is where that intimacy gets tested.
Courts of last resort have guarded against the danger that the true issues will be obscured and confused by giving the trial court discretion to limit the number of such witnesses and to control cross-examination. Propriety and abuse alike depend on "numerous and subtle considerations difficult to detect or appraise from a cold record," so appellate courts disturb these rulings only rarely and on a clear showing of prejudicial abuse of discretion.6
The dissent would not leave the matter there. It argued that it is not enough "to trust to the sound discretion of trial judges to protect the defendant against excesses of the prosecution," because judges need standards to do that effectively, and none are provided under the Court's ruling. The dissent added that standards would be hard to supply except for each case and question as they arise.7 The practical lesson for a lawyer is that the limits on this questioning get fought out case by case in front of the trial judge.
The testing opens from the defense side only. Michelson treats as common ground that, whatever the differences in logic among the rules, "[n]o one would open the doors initially to the prosecution. No one would close them to the defense." That tradition lies at the heart of the criminal process and supports the rule that denies the prosecution "the right to show generally or by specific details that a defendant bears a bad general estimate in his community." The opinion sees "nothing anomalous in this exclusion."8 The prosecution's power to probe a reputation witness thus comes from the accused's own offer of proof, which is why the Court called it the price of attempting to prove a good name.9
A formal character witness is not the only way to open the door. In Government of the Virgin Islands v. Roldan, the defense brought out, while cross-examining a Government witness, that the defendant never bothered anybody. On redirect the Government asked whether the witness knew of the defendant's earlier conviction, and the court held that the defense had put character in issue and allowed the question. What mattered was the defense's own portrait of the accused, because once the defense puts that portrait forward, the Government may test what it leaves out.