Concept
Peculiar Risk Versus Abnormal Danger
Nondelegable duties and inherently dangerous work exceptions
Peculiar Risk Versus Abnormal Danger
Peculiar-risk work and abnormally dangerous work can both make a hirer answer for what an independent contractor does, but they split on the point examiners test most: whether the contractor's negligence is required. A hirer who contracts out an abnormally dangerous activity is liable without regard to the contractor's negligence. A hirer of work that is merely inherently dangerous is liable when the contractor is negligent with respect to the unusual risk.1
The abnormal-danger rule begins with § 519 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts. One who carries on an abnormally dangerous activity is subject to liability for harm to the person, land, or chattels of another resulting from the activity, "although he has exercised the utmost care to prevent the harm."2 In Falls v. Scott, the Kansas Supreme Court recited the Restatement's tests and noted that it had adopted §§ 519 and 520 in Williams v. Amoco Production Co. Among the § 520 factors, two do most of the work in these cases: whether the risk can be eliminated by the exercise of reasonable care, and whether the activity is a matter of common usage. The court also listed the inappropriateness of the activity to its location and the extent to which its value to the community is outweighed by its dangerous attributes.3
The Majestic court drew the same line between the two categories. It held that the principal is liable for both inherently dangerous and ultrahazardous activities, but it treated the ultrahazardous case as the one in which the principal is liable without regard to the contractor's negligence.4 The contractor's care therefore decides the inherently dangerous case and has no bearing on the ultrahazardous one.
The reasons for the split show up in how a hirer can control each kind of risk. In Anderson v. Marathon Petroleum Co., Posner observed that a principal ordinarily does not supervise the contractor's work directly and so has little ability to prevent the contractor's negligence. That reasoning does not carry over to abnormally dangerous activities, which are by definition ones that "might very well result in injury even if conducted with all due skill and caution."5 A negligence rule cannot reach a risk that survives careful work. Peculiar-risk work has the opposite profile. When the job calls for particular precautions known in advance, the hirer can write them into the contract and penalize their omission, and enforcement is cheap when the precautions are easy to observe.6 Liability for peculiar-risk work therefore attaches to the failure to take the precautions.
The two categories also differ in breadth. Blasting is the textbook abnormally dangerous activity, and it clearly falls within the exception, but "inherently dangerous" is much broader than "abnormally dangerous." A typical case is the construction, repair, or maintenance of a structure, which often creates special dangers to those nearby.7 The same source contrasts a contractor who hauls potatoes, whose truck creates no special danger, with one hired to carry explosives or huge logs that are unusually dangerous if not securely fastened. The employer of the second contractor may be vicariously liable when the contractor is negligent with respect to the unusual risk.8 The Restatement Third likewise lists abnormally dangerous activities and activities posing a peculiar risk as separate situations in which a hirer keeps vicarious liability.9 Installing high-voltage electricity shows the gap. It is not so irreducibly dangerous as to be abnormally dangerous, yet it involves an unusual risk, and the Restatement uses it as an illustration.10
The usual error is to call work abnormally dangerous because it is dangerous. The question is whether the § 520 factors are met, above all whether careful performance can eliminate the risk. If they are not met, the stronger argument is that the work required special precautions and the contractor failed to take them.