Also known as:independent adoption · private adoption · direct placement adoption
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
An adoption process in which natural parents contract directly with adoptive parents for placement of the child. The arrangement is lawful only in jurisdictions that expressly authorize independent placements. A small number of states further permit nonagency professionals such as attorneys or physicians to serve as limited intermediaries.
Sources & Authorities
How it applies
Common Examples
2
Direct Placement in Permissive State
Imani Idowu, a pregnant resident of State X, meets directly with Isaiah Ishikawa and his spouse. They execute a placement agreement without any licensed agency. Because State X permits independent adoptions, the court approves the petition and terminates Imani's parental rights upon birth.
Unlicensed Intermediary in Restrictive State
Irene Ingalls confides in her fertility nurse about placing her child. The nurse introduces Irene to Igor Ito and his spouse and helps arrange meetings and draft a contract outside any agency. The state permits only agency-mediated adoptions, so the court denies the petition on the ground that the nurse acted as an unlawful private intermediary.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Common Law
Casebooks
Caban v. Mohammed441 U.S. 380 (1979)
Common questions
Frequently Asked
3
In which states are independent adoptions lawful?+
Independent adoptions are lawful only in those states that expressly permit natural parents to contract directly with adoptive parents. Other states restrict placements to licensed agencies. The governing statute of the forum therefore controls validity.
Supporting sources
May an attorney serve as an intermediary in an independent adoption?+
Only a few states allow nonagency professionals such as attorneys to act as intermediaries. Even in permissive states the attorney may perform only ministerial tasks and may not engage in dual representation or active solicitation.
Supporting sources
Does the presence of an unlicensed intermediary invalidate an otherwise direct placement?+
Yes. When a state permits independent adoptions it still bars unlicensed persons from arranging or facilitating the placement. Conduct such as matching parties, hosting meetings, or charging coordination fees converts the arrangement into an unlawful intermediary placement.
Supporting sources
441 U.S. 380 (1979)Family Law
…considering adoptions will be dissuaded out of fear of subsequent annoyance and entanglements. A 1961 study in Florida of 500 independent adoptions showed that 16% of the couples who had direct contact with the natural parents reported subsequent harassment, compared with only 2% of couples who had no contact (Isaac, Adopting a Child…