On April 10, 1902, Louisa M. Gerry leased the Hotel Bristol at the northwest corner of Forty-second Street and Fifth Avenue in New York City to Walter J. Salmon for a twenty-year term beginning May 1, 1902, and ending April 30, 1922. The lease required Salmon to convert the building into shops and offices at a cost of two hundred thousand dollars. All alterations became accretions to the land.
While negotiating the lease with Gerry, Salmon entered into a joint venture agreement with Morton H. Meinhard. Meinhard agreed to pay half the funds needed to reconstruct, alter, manage, and operate the property. Salmon received sole power to manage, lease, underlet, and operate the building. Net profits were to be divided forty percent to Meinhard for the first five years and fifty percent thereafter. Losses were to be shared equally.
The venture operated the reconstructed property at a loss in its early years and later at a profit. It generated substantial returns for both parties until the lease approached its end.
In late 1921, Elbridge T. Gerry, who had acquired the reversion and owned adjoining lots on Fifth Avenue and Forty-second Street, approached Salmon alone after failing to interest other parties in a larger development plan. On January 25, 1922, Gerry executed a new lease to Midpoint Realty Company, a corporation owned and controlled by Salmon. The new lease covered the entire tract for twenty years with successive renewal options extending up to eighty years. It required demolition of existing buildings after seven years and construction of a new three-million-dollar building. Annual rents ranged from three hundred fifty thousand to four hundred seventy-five thousand dollars. Salmon personally guaranteed performance until the new building was completed and paid for.
Salmon did not inform Meinhard of the negotiations or the new lease until February 1922. Upon learning of it, Meinhard demanded that the lease be held in trust for the venture and offered to share the guaranty obligations. Salmon refused, prompting this suit.
A referee awarded Meinhard a twenty-five percent interest in the lease. On cross-appeals the Appellate Division modified the judgment to enlarge the interest to one-half of the entire lease. The defendants appealed. Separately, in 1917 Meinhard had assigned his entire interest in the joint venture agreement to his wife. She reassigned it to him before suit was commenced. Salmon continued to deal with Meinhard on the basis that the enterprise remained subsisting.
View case