Also known as: plea negotiations · plea negotiate · plea negotiated · plea negotiating · plea bargaining · plea bargain
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
Discussions between a prosecutor and defense counsel aimed at resolving criminal charges through a guilty plea in exchange for concessions on sentencing or charges. The process constitutes a critical stage at which the Sixth Amendment right to counsel attaches. Statements made during these discussions receive protection from later use against the defendant unless a knowing and voluntary waiver occurs.
Piper Patel faced federal fraud charges and met with prosecutors to explore a plea. She signed a written waiver of evidentiary protections before making statements. At trial after the deal collapsed, the government used those statements to impeach her testimony on cross-examination.
Phuong Pham negotiated a plea after indictment on drug charges. The parties discussed facts that would affect the applicable sentencing range. The court later applied those facts when imposing sentence under the advisory guidelines.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Pilar Pena received a plea offer from the prosecutor. Her attorney never conveyed the terms to her before the deadline passed. The court later examined whether that omission satisfied the performance prong of an ineffective-assistance claim.
Pearl Porter considered accepting a plea deal that waived certain rights. Prosecutors withheld impeachment material about a key witness. The court assessed whether the nondisclosure rendered the plea involuntary.
Penelope Price met with prosecutors to discuss possible cooperation in exchange for immunity. She produced documents under a grant of immunity tied to the plea talks. The government later sought to use the documents in a separate prosecution.
Patricia Patel entered a plea to a reduced charge. The parties stipulated to facts that would increase the maximum sentence. The court treated those facts as admitted when calculating the final sentence.
The Sixth Amendment right to counsel attaches at the initiation of adversarial proceedings, including plea discussions that occur after indictment. Counsel must be present or the defendant must waive the right knowingly. Failure to provide counsel at this stage can invalidate statements or the resulting plea.
Supporting sources
Statements made during plea negotiations are generally inadmissible against the defendant under Federal Rule of Evidence 410. A defendant may waive this protection through a knowing and voluntary agreement. Once waived, the statements may be used for impeachment or other limited purposes.
Supporting sources
A defendant must demonstrate that counsel's performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness and that a reasonable probability exists the outcome would have differed but for the deficient performance. In the plea context this often requires showing the defendant would have accepted a more favorable offer and that the court would have approved it.
Supporting sources
…after a 90-day investigation in which he was prohibited from using such routine investigative techniques as grand juries, plea bargaining, grants of immunity, or even subpoenas, see § 592(a)(2). The Court also makes much of the fact that "the courts are specifically prevented from reviewing the Attorney General's decision not…