Also known as:rulings · judicial ruling · court ruling
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
A court's decision or order resolving a legal question or issue arising in a proceeding.
Sources & Authorities· 21 primary sources
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Cases
Statutes
Federal Rules
How it applies
Common Examples
6
Objection to Initial Disclosures
Rita Russell and Riverside Healthcare confer under Rule 26(f). Rita objects that initial disclosures are inappropriate and notes the objection in the proposed plan. The court rules on the objection by determining that limited disclosures of insurance policies are required and sets a deadline thirty days later.
Preserving Error in Evidence Ruling
Riley Rivera offers a business record at trial. The court rules to admit the document over Regal Apparel's objection. Regal's counsel timely states on the record the specific ground that the document lacks foundation, preserving the claim that the ruling affected a substantial right.
Ricardo Rojas and Raven Logistics attend a pretrial conference. The court rules in advance that certain emails are admissible, obtaining stipulations on undisputed facts to streamline proof at trial.
Timely Objection to Admitted Evidence
Renee Rogers moves to strike a witness statement after the court rules to admit it. Counsel places the timely objection and specific hearsay ground on the record, satisfying the requirement for preserving error in the ruling.
Ruling on Summary Judgment Motion
Robert Rivera moves for summary judgment. The court rules on the motion without stating findings of fact or conclusions of law, as permitted when deciding a Rule 56 motion.
Offer of Proof After Exclusion Ruling
Ryan Roberts seeks to introduce expert testimony. The court rules to exclude it. Counsel informs the court of the substance through an offer of proof on the record, preserving the claim of error in the ruling.
Common questions
Frequently Asked
4
When must a party object to preserve a claim of error in a ruling admitting evidence?+
A party must make a timely objection or motion to strike on the record and state the specific ground unless apparent from context. The error must also affect a substantial right.
Is a court required to state findings when ruling on a summary judgment motion?+
No. The court need not state findings or conclusions when ruling on a motion under Rule 56.
What must a party do when a court rules to exclude evidence to preserve error?+
The party must inform the court of the substance of the evidence by an offer of proof unless the substance was apparent from context.
How does a court handle an objection that initial disclosures are inappropriate?+
The court determines what disclosures, if any, are to be made and sets the time for disclosure.
410 U.S. 113 (1973)Constitutional Law
…as it granted Dr. Hallford relief and failed to dismiss his complaint in intervention. C. The Does. In view of our ruling as to Roe's standing in her case, the issue of the Does' standing in their case has little significance. The claims they assert are essentially the same as those of Roe, and they attack the…