Also known as: wanton reckless · recklessness
Written by attorneys · grounded in primary & secondary sources — see below
Extreme recklessness manifesting a depraved indifference to the value of human life. This mental state satisfies the malice aforethought requirement for murder at common law when it creates an unjustifiably high risk of death.
Whitney White, a dispatcher at Frontier Cargo, received an explicit report that a driver had nearly fallen asleep during a double shift and that icy conditions were forecast. She directed the driver to proceed anyway to avoid overtime costs and meet contract deadlines. When the bus later skidded on ice and killed a passenger, her decision to send the fatigued driver onto the hazardous route despite the known warnings demonstrated wanton recklessness.
Wanda Weaver, a producer at Gold News, received a written safety report warning that high-speed forklifts without barriers created an obvious probability of death during a live stunt. She approved the stunt anyway to boost ratings and dismissed engineer recommendations to add barriers or reduce speed. When a contestant was killed, her conscious choice to proceed despite the concrete lethal risk reflected wanton recklessness.
Select any source to read its text and confirm it supports the definition.
Wade Watson, the general partner of Riverwalk Apartments, received repeated written building-code citations declaring balconies structurally unsafe and ordering immediate repair. He directed staff to ignore the orders to preserve cash for another acquisition and continued leasing the units. When a tenant was injured, his knowing refusal to correct the documented hazard constituted wanton recklessness.
Willa Whitman, a nurse at Nova Health, conspired with a colleague to steal diagnostic devices from a locked storage room after hours. When an elderly patient's bed blocked their path, she injected the patient with an unauthorized large dose of sedative to clear the way. The patient died from respiratory arrest, and her deliberate creation of a lethal risk to advance the felony showed wanton recklessness.
Winona Walsh, a professor at River University, locked a graduate student in a lab after accusing him of plagiarism. After the student warned that continued pressure would kill him, she maintained the cord around his neck for several minutes while he struggled. The student's death by asphyxiation resulted from her conscious disregard of the known lethal risk.
Whitney Washington, operations partner at Apex Precision Partners, repeatedly overrode the manufacturer's maintenance schedule and manually disabled mandatory safety sensors on a hydraulic press to avoid production delays. State regulations and plant rules required the sensors to remain active. When the press failed and severely injured an employee, her knowing removal of the required safeguards demonstrated wanton recklessness.
Wanton recklessness requires a higher degree of risk and indifference than the recklessness sufficient for manslaughter. It must manifest depraved indifference to an unjustifiably high risk of death, elevating the killing to murder under the abandoned-and-malignant-heart theory.
Supporting sources
Yes. At common law, extreme recklessness demonstrating a depraved heart supplies implied malice even without a purpose to kill. The conscious disregard of a known lethal risk for non-essential reasons meets the standard.
Supporting sources
No. The mental state focuses on the conscious disregard of a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death, not on whether the actor hoped to escape blame. Explicit warnings of probable death followed by continued conduct establish the required indifference.
Supporting sources
No. Involuntary manslaughter requires only criminal negligence or a lesser degree of recklessness that creates a high risk of death or serious bodily harm. Wanton recklessness crosses into the higher threshold needed for murder.
Supporting sources
…charge, however, that the jury must be "convinced" of malice, in the sense of "actual intent" to harm or "gross negligence and recklessness," to make such an award, and he also refused to require that a verdict for respondent differentiate between compensatory and punitive damages. The judge rejected petitioners' contention…